Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Clarifies Anticipatory Bail Rights for Accused in Custody in Another Case

13 Sep 2024

Supreme Court Clarifies Anticipatory Bail Rights for Accused in Custody in Another Case

3

Min Read

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Clarifies Anticipatory Bail Rights for Accused in Custody in Another Case

13 Sep 2024

Supreme Court Clarifies Anticipatory Bail Rights for Accused in Custody in Another Case

3

Min Read

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Clarifies Anticipatory Bail Rights for Accused in Custody in Another Case

13 Sep 2024

Supreme Court Clarifies Anticipatory Bail Rights for Accused in Custody in Another Case

3

Min Read

Introduction

In a landmark decision titled Dhanraj Aswani v. Amar S. Mulchandani[^i], the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that a person has the right to seek anticipatory bail as per provisions of s. 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (‘CrPC’) in connection with an offence for which he has not been arrested. There is no restriction upon the accused from seeking a remedy under s. 438 of the CrPC by reason of him/her already being in custody. While adjudicating upon the aforementioned issue, which has been lingering for several years, the Supreme Court has discussed various judicial pronouncements pertaining to bail jurisprudence, briefly discussed below.

Brief Facts

  • A first information report (‘FIR’) was registered against the accused/Respondent under various sections of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) by the complainant/Appellant while the Respondent was already in custody in a matter relating to the offence of money laundering.

  • Subsequent to filing the aforementioned FIR, the Respondent approached the Hon’ble Bombay High Court seeking anticipatory bail under s. 438 of the CrPC.

  • During the hearing of the anticipatory bail application by the Bombay High Court, the Appellant intervened and objected to the maintainability of the anticipatory bail application filed by the Respondent. The Appellant contended that the Respondent was already in custody in some other matter, and hence, an application for anticipatory bail under s. 438 of the CrPC would not lie unless the Respondent first surrenders himself before the investigating body.

  • The High Court overruled the submissions made by the Appellant, and the Respondent’s anticipatory bail application was allowed. Aggrieved by such observation, the Appellant approached the Supreme Court.

Issue

Whether an application for anticipatory bail under s. 438 of the CrPC was maintainable when an accused is already in judicial custody in connection with a different case/matter.

Held

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal filed by the Appellant. It held that an under-custody accused is entitled to seek anticipatory bail if he has a ‘reasonable belief’ that he may be arrested in relation to some other non-bailable offence while making the following observations:

  • The only precondition for applying for pre-arrest bail is ‘reason to believe,’ and there is no bar, express or implied, under CrPC restricting the right to seek anticipatory bail except for offences already barred by s. 438(4) of the CrPC.

  • While examining the scheme of CrPC, the Court observed that the rights of both the accused and the investigating agency in relation to each subsequent offence ought to be independently protected. i.e., while the accused has the right to seek anticipatory bail for each offence, the investigating agency may also seek remand for each offence.

  • The Court, in consonance with the submissions made by the Respondent, accepted that the provision for anticipatory bail under CrPC is protected by a. 21 of the Constitution of India ('Constitution'), and such right to protect personal liberty cannot be thwarted without a valid procedure established by law. Furthermore, such procedure should pass the test of fairness and reasonableness and manifest non-arbitrariness on the anvil of a. 14 of the Constitution.

Our Analysis

This decision by the Supreme Court comes as another significant development in recent decisions by the Court restoring bail jurisprudence to its full glory[^ii] and granting bail for serious offences such as money laundering. The Supreme Court went into the intricacy of the fundamentals of bail, such as the meaning of ‘arrest’ and ‘custody’ and validly observed that many times, multiple subsequent FIRs can be used as a tool to continuously incarcerate a person who is already under custody or remand and denying an individual of their right to seek anticipatory bail in such a scenario would be in gross violation of the object and intent of CrPC. Furthermore, the Supreme Court rightly rejected the contention of the Appellant that the right to seek anticipatory bail is merely a statutory right and not a fundamental right by holding that such right is well protected under a. 21 of the Constitution. This wide meaning of ‘custody’ adopted by the Supreme Court would also aid individuals under remand or custody of special agencies like ED to seek statutory relief under CrPC. In conclusion, this judgement is a welcome step in expanding bail jurisprudence in India.

End Notes

[^i]:  2024 SCC OnLine SC 2453.

[^ii]: For an in-depth perspective, check out the analysis by our associate Anshi Bhatia - Is the ED’s Era on the Brink of Collapse?

Authored by Aditya Gupta at Metalegal Advocates. The views expressed are personal and do not constitute legal opinions.

More Insights

Cover image for the article: Wealth Without a Will Is a Legal Vacuum

01 Jan 2026

6

Min Read

Wealth without a Will Is a Legal Vacuum

Wealth without a will does not pass in silence; it passes under statute. When intention is unexpressed, the law steps in with mechanical rules that distribute entitlement but cannot preserve context, dignity, or harmony. Intestate succession offers certainty of rule, not certainty of outcome. A will is not an assertion of control beyond death, but an assumption of responsibility during life.

Stone columns and an ornate ceiling beneath a gridded skylight

29 May 2025

5

Min Read

Can a Spouse Be Convicted for Abetment under the PC Act? Supreme Court Delivers a Split Verdict

In P. Nallammal v. State, the Supreme Court delivered a split verdict on whether a public servant’s spouse can be convicted for abetting the accumulation of disproportionate assets. While both judges upheld asset attachment and procedural findings, they diverged sharply on the standards required to prove abetment under Section 109 IPC read with the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.

Cover image for the article: [Supreme Court] No Privilege of Anticipatory Bail for Accused Persons Who Deliberately Dodged Court Summons

20 Apr 2025

5

Min Read

[Supreme Court] No Privilege of Anticipatory Bail for Accused Persons Who Deliberately Dodged Court Summons

The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s grant of anticipatory bail to accused persons declared proclaimed offenders for evading summons in a major economic fraud. Reaffirming that anticipatory bail is a discretionary relief, the Court held that wilful evasion of judicial process disentitles accused persons from seeking such protection, especially in grave financial crimes involving public interest.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Reiterates — Not All Provocation Will Reduce The Crime Of Murder To Culpable Homicide

26 Jan 2025

4

Min Read

Supreme Court Reiterates — Not All Provocation Will Reduce the Crime of Murder to Culpable Homicide

The SC explains the conditions for applying the exception of grave and sudden provocation under s. 300 of the IPC in homicide cases.

Cover image for the article: RBI’s New Master Direction: A Comprehensive Framework for Non-Resident Investment in Debt Instruments

15 Jan 2025

5

Min Read

RBI’s New Master Direction: A Comprehensive Framework for Non-Resident Investment in Debt Instruments

The RBI’s 2025 Master Direction simplifies non-resident investment in India’s debt markets, enhancing regulatory clarity and access.

Cover image for the article: The Conflict of Interest in Representing Multiple Accused Persons in Criminal Matters

26 Dec 2024

5

Min Read

The Conflict of Interest in Representing Multiple Accused Persons in Criminal Matters

In criminal cases, especially in economic offences, it is common to see one lawyer representing multiple accused persons. While this may appear convenient, the practice raises serious concerns about conflict of interest, attorney-client privilege, and the fairness of proceedings. This Insight explores why joint representation is problematic, how it can undermine the rights of the accused, and what the legal position on the issue is.

Cover image for the article: Interpreting Custodial Limits: Karnataka High Court Clarifies Section 187 of the BNSS as Against Section 167 of the CrPC

22 Dec 2024

4

Min Read

Interpreting Custodial Limits: Karnataka High Court Clarifies Section 187 of the BNSS as against Section 167 of the CrPC

The Karnataka High Court examines custodial limits under BNSS, balancing investigation needs with constitutional liberty safeguards.

Cover image for the article: Presumption of Guilt: Supreme Court Restores Conviction in Corruption Case under Prevention of Corruption Act

06 Dec 2024

4

Min Read

Presumption of Guilt: Supreme Court Restores Conviction in Corruption Case under Prevention of Corruption Act

The SC restores conviction in a bribery case, reinforcing evidentiary standards and accountability under the Prevention of Corruption Act.

Cover image for the article: Cyber Fraud and Bank Liability: Delhi HC Ruling on RBI Consumer Protection

29 Nov 2024

6

Min Read

Cyber Fraud and Bank Liability: Delhi HC Ruling on RBI Consumer Protection

Delhi High Court clarifies banks’ liability in cyber fraud cases, reinforcing RBI’s consumer protection framework against digital scams.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Takes a Stand Against Caste-Based Prison Discrimination

17 Oct 2024

7

Min Read

Supreme Court Takes a Stand against Caste-Based Prison Discrimination

The Supreme Court mandates States to revise prison manuals, eliminate caste-based discrimination, ensure equality, and protect dignity,

Cover image for the article: A Shift in Judicial Approach: Understanding Section 482 of the BNSS, 2023

30 Sep 2024

3

Min Read

A Shift in Judicial Approach: Understanding Section 482 of the BNSS, 2023

Chhattisgarh High Court broadens anticipatory bail criteria, enhancing judicial discretion and prioritising personal liberty.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court on Anticipatory Bail under SC/ST Act: Interpretation of Sections 18 and 3

30 Aug 2024

6

Min Read

Supreme Court on Anticipatory Bail under SC/ST Act: Interpretation of Sections 18 and 3

Exploring the Supreme Court's nuanced stance on anticipatory bail within the SC/ST Act through pivotal rulings.

Cover image for the article: Excessive Bail is no Bail – Supreme Court Relaxes Bail Conditions

29 Aug 2024

3

Min Read

Excessive Bail Is No Bail – Supreme Court Relaxes Bail Conditions

SC rules on unified sureties for multiple FIRs, easing the bail process across states, upholding fundamental rights under Article 21

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Acquits Accused Due to Inadmissible Evidence and Procedural Lapses in NDPS Case

28 Aug 2024

3

Min Read

Supreme Court Acquits Accused Due to Inadmissible Evidence and Procedural Lapses in NDPS Case

Analysis of a landmark Supreme Court verdict, highlighting key legal errors in NDPS convictions and procedural integrity

Cover image for the article: Acquittal in Cheque Bounce Case: Supreme Court Emphasises Evidence Over Presumption

15 Aug 2024

4

Min Read

Acquittal in Cheque Bounce Case: Supreme Court Emphasises Evidence over Presumption

SC upholds acquittal in cheque bounce case, emphasising robust evidence over mere legal presumption.

Cover image for the article: Beyond the Basics: A Comprehensive Guide to Bail Cancellation - Jurisdiction, Grounds, and Proof

05 Aug 2024

11

Min Read

Beyond the Basics: A Comprehensive Guide to Bail Cancellation - Jurisdiction, Grounds, and Proof

Explore the jurisprudence of bail cancellation, including judicial criteria and proof burdens.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Upholds Strict Application of S. 80 of the CPC in Limitation Cases

28 Jul 2024

3

Min Read

Supreme Court Upholds Strict Application of S. 80 of the CPC in Limitation Cases

SC mandates notice under CPC s.80 before suits against the government, stressing strict procedural compliance.

Cover image for the article: The Seriousness of the Charges Cannot Come in the Way of the Constitutional Right to Speedy Trial: Supreme Court

27 Jul 2024

4

Min Read

The Seriousness of the Charges Cannot Come in the Way of the Constitutional Right to Speedy Trial: Supreme Court

The seriousness of the charges cannot come in the way of the constitutional right to speedy trial: Supreme Court

Cover image for the article: Uttarakhand High Court Upholds Cancellation of Bail Obtained Through Misrepresentation/Fraud

15 Jul 2024

4

Min Read

Uttarakhand High Court Upholds Cancellation of Bail Obtained through Misrepresentation/Fraud

Uttarakhand HC denies bail due to undisclosed criminal history, affirming the need for transparency.

Cover image for the article: Applicability of S. 202 of the CrPC in Summoning an Accused Residing Outside the Territorial Jurisdiction of the Court

14 Jun 2024

4

Min Read

Applicability of S. 202 of the CrPC in Summoning an Accused Residing Outside the Territorial Jurisdiction of the Court

Allahabad HC clarifies s. 202 CrPC's scope in cross-jurisdictional summoning cases.

Decorative architectural panels above arched windows

14 Jun 2024

8

Min Read

Navigating Personal Insolvency: Transformative Insights into India’s Legal Landscape

Explore the transformative impact of the IBC on personal insolvency in India, unveiling a structured path for individual debtors.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Directs Manish Sisodia to Revive Bail Application After Charge Sheet Filing

11 Jun 2024

2

Min Read

Supreme Court Directs Manish Sisodia to Revive Bail Application after Charge Sheet Filing

Exploring SC's nuanced decision on Sisodia's ongoing bail saga, focusing on procedural diligence and rights.

Cover image for the article: Accused Under PMLA Can Travel Abroad Without Restrictions If the Nature of His Profession Requires International Travel

07 Jun 2024

2

Min Read

Accused under PMLA Can Travel Abroad without Restrictions if the Nature of His Profession Requires International Travel

Bombay HC ruling supports work-related global travel for PMLA cases, balancing legal oversight with career needs.

Stone columns and an ornate ceiling beneath a gridded skylight

05 Jun 2024

2

Min Read

Supreme Court Upholds Liberty against Stringent NDPS Bail Conditions

SC decision frees man after 2 years, highlighting the right to a speedy trial and justice over strict NDPS bail rules.

Cover image for the article: Upholding Constitutional Rights: Prabir v. State (NCT of Delhi)

24 May 2024

3

Min Read

Upholding Constitutional Rights: Prabir v. State (NCT of Delhi)

SC upholds constitutional rights in Prabir v. State (NCT of Delhi), emphasising the necessity of written grounds for arrest.

Cover image for the article: Non-Bailable Warrants Will Not Be Issued Unless the Accused Is Likely to Abscond or Destroy Evidence

13 May 2024

3

Min Read

Non-Bailable Warrants Will Not Be Issued Unless the Accused Is Likely to Abscond or Destroy Evidence

Supreme Court clarifies when non-bailable warrants can be issued, emphasising individual liberty and case-specific scrutiny.

Cover image for the article: Legality of Summons Issued for Attendance During Investigation

13 May 2024

9

Min Read

Legality of Summons Issued for Attendance During Investigation

Explore the critical role of summonses in legal investigations, ensuring compliance and procedural fairness.

Cover image for the article: The Supreme Court Grants Interim Bail to the Petitioner Due to An Anomaly in the Documents Presented

12 May 2024

3

Min Read

The Supreme Court Grants Interim Bail to the Petitioner Due to an Anomaly in the Documents Presented

SC grants interim bail in Sandeep Gupta v. ED due to document anomalies, ensuring due process.

Cover image for the article: Delhi HC Clarifies the Bounds of Vicarious Liability under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881

01 May 2024

3

Min Read

Delhi HC Clarifies the Bounds of Vicarious Liability under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881

DHC's ruling reinforces clear distinctions in corporate liabilities, stressing precise legal pleadings for vicarious claims.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Quashes Criminal Proceedings in Cheque Dishonour Case After Full Compensation

12 Apr 2024

4

Min Read

Supreme Court Quashes Criminal Proceedings in Cheque Dishonour Case after Full Compensation

SC quashes cheque dishonour case, highlights civil vs. criminal liabilities, and redefines consent in compounding offences under NI Act.