Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Quashes Criminal Proceedings in Cheque Dishonour Case After Full Compensation

12 Apr 2024

Supreme Court Quashes Criminal Proceedings in Cheque Dishonour Case after Full Compensation

4

Min Read

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Quashes Criminal Proceedings in Cheque Dishonour Case After Full Compensation

12 Apr 2024

Supreme Court Quashes Criminal Proceedings in Cheque Dishonour Case after Full Compensation

4

Min Read

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Quashes Criminal Proceedings in Cheque Dishonour Case After Full Compensation

12 Apr 2024

Supreme Court Quashes Criminal Proceedings in Cheque Dishonour Case after Full Compensation

4

Min Read

Introduction

In the realm of legal jurisprudence, the intersection of civil transactions and criminal liabilities often presents intriguing scenarios. A recent judgment by the Supreme Court of India (‘SC’) provides a compelling examination of this interplay. The case in question, Raj Reddy Kallem v. State of Haryana[^i], revolves around the Appellant’s failure to deliver a Promotec Fiber Laser Cutting Machine (‘PFLC machine’) despite receiving an advance payment, leading to a series of legal proceedings under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (‘NI Act’) and the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (‘IPC’). This case brings to light the nuances of compounding offences under the NI Act and the role of consent in such proceedings.

Brief Facts

  • In 2012, the Complainant placed a purchase order for a PFLC machine with the Appellant’s company, M/s Farmax. An advance payment of Rs. 1.55 crores was made. However, Farmax failed to supply the machine to the Complainant, and hence, the Appellant issued 5 cheques to return the advance money. Some cheques were dishonoured, leading to proceedings under s. 138 of the NI Act. Thereafter, the Complainant filed a complaint under s. 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (‘CrPC’), leading to a first information report (‘FIR’) being registered under ss. 406, 420, and 120B of the IPC against the Appellant. The Appellant was convicted under s. 138 of the NI Act by the trial court and sentenced to 2 years of rigorous imprisonment. He was also directed to pay the amount of the cheques to the Complainant.

  • The Appellant challenged the conviction before the Additional Sessions Judge (‘ASJ’), whereby both parties attempted to settle the dispute and reached a settlement in the Lok Adalat. The Appellant agreed to pay back the entire amount of Rs. 1.55 crores within about 16 months. However, the Appellant failed to do so, leading to the ASJ declaring the settlement frustrated.

  • Between 2016 and 2020, the Appellant approached various courts seeking an extension of time to pay back the amount. The Appellant’s wife filed a special leave petition (‘SLP’) before the SC, which directed her to deposit Rs. 20 lakhs before the trial court within 3 weeks, as only Rs. 20 lakhs were remaining out of the total amount of Rs. 1.55 crores at that time. The Appellant’s wife failed to comply with the order, leading to the dismissal of the SLP.

  • Subsequently, the Appellant approached the trial court and presented a demand draft of Rs. 20 lakhs in favour of the Complainant. He prayed that the criminal proceedings against him should either be quashed or compounded. However, the trial court refused to accept the demand draft and dismissed the application as not maintainable, considering the submission of the Complainant that the SLP in which the Appellant’s wife was directed to deposit Rs. 20 lakhs had already been dismissed.

  • This order was challenged before the High Court (‘HC’) by the Appellant through an application under s. 482 of the CrPC. The HC dismissed the application on the ground that the Appellant had failed to deposit Rs. 20 lakhs within 3 weeks as per the SC directions, leading to the present appeal before the SC.

Held

  • The SC allowed the appeal and set aside the HC’s order. It quashed all criminal proceedings against the Appellant and set aside the conviction and sentence awarded thereby. The SC noted that the Appellant had fully compensated the Complainant, including Rs. 10 lakhs as interest for delayed payment.

  • The SC observed that the Appellant had already been in jail for more than a year before being released on bail and had compensated the Complainant. It held that the transaction between the parties was purely civil in nature and did not attract criminal law. The SC differentiated between the quashing of a case and compounding, stating that quashing is applied by the Court, while compounding is primarily based on the consent of the injured party. The SC held that even though the Complainant was unwilling to compound the case, considering the totality of facts and circumstances, the proceedings must come to an end.

  • The SC referred to its previous judgments, stating that in cases of s. 138 of the NI Act, the accused must try for compounding at the initial stages. However, there is no bar to seek the compounding of the offence at later stages of criminal proceedings, including after conviction.

Our Analysis

This judgment brings to the fore the complexities involved in the compounding of offences under the NI Act. The SC’s decision to quash the criminal proceedings, despite the Complainant’s unwillingness to compound the case, is noteworthy. The judgment highlights a critical issue regarding the necessity of consent in compounding offences under the NI Act. While the SC stated that compounding occurs with consent, there was no consent of the Complainant in this case. This raises questions about the role and importance of consent in the compounding of offences under the NI Act. Furthermore, the SC observed that this case involved a transaction between the parties that was purely civil in nature. It is a practical reality that most offences under the NI Act usually involve purely civil transactions only, raising further questions about the classification of offences under the NI Act.

Having said that, the impact of this decision is significant. It sets a precedent for future cases involving the compounding of offences under the NI Act and provides a fresh perspective on the interpretation of the law. However, it also opens up a Pandora’s box of legal debates and discussions, particularly around the role of consent in the compounding of offences and the nature of transactions under the NI Act. As the legal fraternity grapples with these questions, one thing is clear – this judgment has added a new dimension to the discourse on the compounding of offences under the NI Act.

End Note

[^i]: [2024] 161 taxmann.com 784, [dated: 08.04.2024]

Authored by Srishty Jaura at Metalegal Advocates. The views expressed are personal and do not constitute legal opinion.

Portrait of Srishty Jaura
Portrait of Srishty Jaura

AUTHORED BY

Principal Associate

Principal Associate

Principal Associate

More Insights

Cover image for the article: Wealth Without a Will Is a Legal Vacuum

01 Jan 2026

6

Min Read

Wealth without a Will Is a Legal Vacuum

Wealth without a will does not pass in silence; it passes under statute. When intention is unexpressed, the law steps in with mechanical rules that distribute entitlement but cannot preserve context, dignity, or harmony. Intestate succession offers certainty of rule, not certainty of outcome. A will is not an assertion of control beyond death, but an assumption of responsibility during life.

Stone columns and an ornate ceiling beneath a gridded skylight

29 May 2025

5

Min Read

Can a Spouse Be Convicted for Abetment under the PC Act? Supreme Court Delivers a Split Verdict

In P. Nallammal v. State, the Supreme Court delivered a split verdict on whether a public servant’s spouse can be convicted for abetting the accumulation of disproportionate assets. While both judges upheld asset attachment and procedural findings, they diverged sharply on the standards required to prove abetment under Section 109 IPC read with the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.

Cover image for the article: [Supreme Court] No Privilege of Anticipatory Bail for Accused Persons Who Deliberately Dodged Court Summons

20 Apr 2025

5

Min Read

[Supreme Court] No Privilege of Anticipatory Bail for Accused Persons Who Deliberately Dodged Court Summons

The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s grant of anticipatory bail to accused persons declared proclaimed offenders for evading summons in a major economic fraud. Reaffirming that anticipatory bail is a discretionary relief, the Court held that wilful evasion of judicial process disentitles accused persons from seeking such protection, especially in grave financial crimes involving public interest.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Reiterates — Not All Provocation Will Reduce The Crime Of Murder To Culpable Homicide

26 Jan 2025

4

Min Read

Supreme Court Reiterates — Not All Provocation Will Reduce the Crime of Murder to Culpable Homicide

The SC explains the conditions for applying the exception of grave and sudden provocation under s. 300 of the IPC in homicide cases.

Cover image for the article: RBI’s New Master Direction: A Comprehensive Framework for Non-Resident Investment in Debt Instruments

15 Jan 2025

5

Min Read

RBI’s New Master Direction: A Comprehensive Framework for Non-Resident Investment in Debt Instruments

The RBI’s 2025 Master Direction simplifies non-resident investment in India’s debt markets, enhancing regulatory clarity and access.

Cover image for the article: The Conflict of Interest in Representing Multiple Accused Persons in Criminal Matters

26 Dec 2024

5

Min Read

The Conflict of Interest in Representing Multiple Accused Persons in Criminal Matters

In criminal cases, especially in economic offences, it is common to see one lawyer representing multiple accused persons. While this may appear convenient, the practice raises serious concerns about conflict of interest, attorney-client privilege, and the fairness of proceedings. This Insight explores why joint representation is problematic, how it can undermine the rights of the accused, and what the legal position on the issue is.

Cover image for the article: Interpreting Custodial Limits: Karnataka High Court Clarifies Section 187 of the BNSS as Against Section 167 of the CrPC

22 Dec 2024

4

Min Read

Interpreting Custodial Limits: Karnataka High Court Clarifies Section 187 of the BNSS as against Section 167 of the CrPC

The Karnataka High Court examines custodial limits under BNSS, balancing investigation needs with constitutional liberty safeguards.

Cover image for the article: Presumption of Guilt: Supreme Court Restores Conviction in Corruption Case under Prevention of Corruption Act

06 Dec 2024

4

Min Read

Presumption of Guilt: Supreme Court Restores Conviction in Corruption Case under Prevention of Corruption Act

The SC restores conviction in a bribery case, reinforcing evidentiary standards and accountability under the Prevention of Corruption Act.

Cover image for the article: Cyber Fraud and Bank Liability: Delhi HC Ruling on RBI Consumer Protection

29 Nov 2024

6

Min Read

Cyber Fraud and Bank Liability: Delhi HC Ruling on RBI Consumer Protection

Delhi High Court clarifies banks’ liability in cyber fraud cases, reinforcing RBI’s consumer protection framework against digital scams.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Takes a Stand Against Caste-Based Prison Discrimination

17 Oct 2024

7

Min Read

Supreme Court Takes a Stand against Caste-Based Prison Discrimination

The Supreme Court mandates States to revise prison manuals, eliminate caste-based discrimination, ensure equality, and protect dignity,

Cover image for the article: A Shift in Judicial Approach: Understanding Section 482 of the BNSS, 2023

30 Sep 2024

3

Min Read

A Shift in Judicial Approach: Understanding Section 482 of the BNSS, 2023

Chhattisgarh High Court broadens anticipatory bail criteria, enhancing judicial discretion and prioritising personal liberty.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Clarifies Anticipatory Bail Rights for Accused in Custody in Another Case

13 Sep 2024

3

Min Read

Supreme Court Clarifies Anticipatory Bail Rights for Accused in Custody in Another Case

The SC affirms the right to seek anticipatory bail, even if in custody for a different case, reinforcing the protection of personal liberty.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court on Anticipatory Bail under SC/ST Act: Interpretation of Sections 18 and 3

30 Aug 2024

6

Min Read

Supreme Court on Anticipatory Bail under SC/ST Act: Interpretation of Sections 18 and 3

Exploring the Supreme Court's nuanced stance on anticipatory bail within the SC/ST Act through pivotal rulings.

Cover image for the article: Excessive Bail is no Bail – Supreme Court Relaxes Bail Conditions

29 Aug 2024

3

Min Read

Excessive Bail Is No Bail – Supreme Court Relaxes Bail Conditions

SC rules on unified sureties for multiple FIRs, easing the bail process across states, upholding fundamental rights under Article 21

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Acquits Accused Due to Inadmissible Evidence and Procedural Lapses in NDPS Case

28 Aug 2024

3

Min Read

Supreme Court Acquits Accused Due to Inadmissible Evidence and Procedural Lapses in NDPS Case

Analysis of a landmark Supreme Court verdict, highlighting key legal errors in NDPS convictions and procedural integrity

Cover image for the article: Acquittal in Cheque Bounce Case: Supreme Court Emphasises Evidence Over Presumption

15 Aug 2024

4

Min Read

Acquittal in Cheque Bounce Case: Supreme Court Emphasises Evidence over Presumption

SC upholds acquittal in cheque bounce case, emphasising robust evidence over mere legal presumption.

Cover image for the article: Beyond the Basics: A Comprehensive Guide to Bail Cancellation - Jurisdiction, Grounds, and Proof

05 Aug 2024

11

Min Read

Beyond the Basics: A Comprehensive Guide to Bail Cancellation - Jurisdiction, Grounds, and Proof

Explore the jurisprudence of bail cancellation, including judicial criteria and proof burdens.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Upholds Strict Application of S. 80 of the CPC in Limitation Cases

28 Jul 2024

3

Min Read

Supreme Court Upholds Strict Application of S. 80 of the CPC in Limitation Cases

SC mandates notice under CPC s.80 before suits against the government, stressing strict procedural compliance.

Cover image for the article: The Seriousness of the Charges Cannot Come in the Way of the Constitutional Right to Speedy Trial: Supreme Court

27 Jul 2024

4

Min Read

The Seriousness of the Charges Cannot Come in the Way of the Constitutional Right to Speedy Trial: Supreme Court

The seriousness of the charges cannot come in the way of the constitutional right to speedy trial: Supreme Court

Cover image for the article: Uttarakhand High Court Upholds Cancellation of Bail Obtained Through Misrepresentation/Fraud

15 Jul 2024

4

Min Read

Uttarakhand High Court Upholds Cancellation of Bail Obtained through Misrepresentation/Fraud

Uttarakhand HC denies bail due to undisclosed criminal history, affirming the need for transparency.

Cover image for the article: Applicability of S. 202 of the CrPC in Summoning an Accused Residing Outside the Territorial Jurisdiction of the Court

14 Jun 2024

4

Min Read

Applicability of S. 202 of the CrPC in Summoning an Accused Residing Outside the Territorial Jurisdiction of the Court

Allahabad HC clarifies s. 202 CrPC's scope in cross-jurisdictional summoning cases.

Decorative architectural panels above arched windows

14 Jun 2024

8

Min Read

Navigating Personal Insolvency: Transformative Insights into India’s Legal Landscape

Explore the transformative impact of the IBC on personal insolvency in India, unveiling a structured path for individual debtors.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Directs Manish Sisodia to Revive Bail Application After Charge Sheet Filing

11 Jun 2024

2

Min Read

Supreme Court Directs Manish Sisodia to Revive Bail Application after Charge Sheet Filing

Exploring SC's nuanced decision on Sisodia's ongoing bail saga, focusing on procedural diligence and rights.

Cover image for the article: Accused Under PMLA Can Travel Abroad Without Restrictions If the Nature of His Profession Requires International Travel

07 Jun 2024

2

Min Read

Accused under PMLA Can Travel Abroad without Restrictions if the Nature of His Profession Requires International Travel

Bombay HC ruling supports work-related global travel for PMLA cases, balancing legal oversight with career needs.

Stone columns and an ornate ceiling beneath a gridded skylight

05 Jun 2024

2

Min Read

Supreme Court Upholds Liberty against Stringent NDPS Bail Conditions

SC decision frees man after 2 years, highlighting the right to a speedy trial and justice over strict NDPS bail rules.

Cover image for the article: Upholding Constitutional Rights: Prabir v. State (NCT of Delhi)

24 May 2024

3

Min Read

Upholding Constitutional Rights: Prabir v. State (NCT of Delhi)

SC upholds constitutional rights in Prabir v. State (NCT of Delhi), emphasising the necessity of written grounds for arrest.

Cover image for the article: Non-Bailable Warrants Will Not Be Issued Unless the Accused Is Likely to Abscond or Destroy Evidence

13 May 2024

3

Min Read

Non-Bailable Warrants Will Not Be Issued Unless the Accused Is Likely to Abscond or Destroy Evidence

Supreme Court clarifies when non-bailable warrants can be issued, emphasising individual liberty and case-specific scrutiny.

Cover image for the article: Legality of Summons Issued for Attendance During Investigation

13 May 2024

9

Min Read

Legality of Summons Issued for Attendance During Investigation

Explore the critical role of summonses in legal investigations, ensuring compliance and procedural fairness.

Cover image for the article: The Supreme Court Grants Interim Bail to the Petitioner Due to An Anomaly in the Documents Presented

12 May 2024

3

Min Read

The Supreme Court Grants Interim Bail to the Petitioner Due to an Anomaly in the Documents Presented

SC grants interim bail in Sandeep Gupta v. ED due to document anomalies, ensuring due process.

Cover image for the article: Delhi HC Clarifies the Bounds of Vicarious Liability under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881

01 May 2024

3

Min Read

Delhi HC Clarifies the Bounds of Vicarious Liability under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881

DHC's ruling reinforces clear distinctions in corporate liabilities, stressing precise legal pleadings for vicarious claims.