Cover image for the article: Validity of Unregistered Agreement: ITAT holds that the Law Does Not Require an Agreement to be in Writing

15 Jan 2024

Validity of Unregistered Agreement: ITAT Holds that the Law Does Not Require an Agreement to Be in Writing

4

Min Read

Cover image for the article: Validity of Unregistered Agreement: ITAT holds that the Law Does Not Require an Agreement to be in Writing

15 Jan 2024

Validity of Unregistered Agreement: ITAT Holds that the Law Does Not Require an Agreement to Be in Writing

4

Min Read

Cover image for the article: Validity of Unregistered Agreement: ITAT holds that the Law Does Not Require an Agreement to be in Writing

15 Jan 2024

Validity of Unregistered Agreement: ITAT Holds that the Law Does Not Require an Agreement to Be in Writing

4

Min Read

Introduction

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (‘Tribunal’), Jabalpur Bench, made a significant decision in ACIT v. Rajul Constructions,[^i] and discussed the application of s. 43CA of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (‘IT Act’). The Tribunal categorically stated that there is no provision in the IT Act or the General Clauses Act, 1897 that defines the word ‘agreement’. Additionally, no law requires the agreement for the contract of sale of immovable property to be necessarily in writing, for applying the law under s. 43CA of the IT Act, an oral agreement has the same value as a written and formal agreement. The Tribunal also noted that repeatedly having the same witnesses should not lead to an adverse inference against the assessee without any application of mind.

Brief Facts

  • The assessee, a builder and land developer, held plots as stock-in-trade during the assessment year (‘AY’) 2015-16. The booking of 40 plots sold by the assessee during the AY 2015-2016 was spread across multiple financial years: 15 plots in 2009-10, 10 plots in 2010-11, 6 plots in 2013-14, and 9 in 2014-15. The total sales for the relevant AY were reflected as Rs. 5,37,41,093/- in the profit and loss account.

  • The assessing officer (‘AO’) determined that the consideration received by the assessee for the plot sales was lower than the value assessed by the stamp valuation authority. Consequently, as per s. 43CA of the IT Act, the AO treated the stamp duty value as the full value of consideration received from the transfers. The AO held that unregistered sale agreements cannot be legally recognised. Additionally, in certain cases, the parties who made advance payments differed from those to whom the property was eventually registered. Based on these findings, the AO calculated the difference between the actual sale consideration and the properties’ market value to add to the assessee’s income under s. 43CA and alleged that the assessee’s actions displayed an attempt to evade tax.

  • Furthermore, an adverse conclusion was drawn by the AO based on the fact that the agreements were signed by the same persons, Shri R.S. Mishra, Shri Dilip Mishra and Shri Rajendra Tiwari as witnesses despite the change in the years over a prolonged period of 2009 to 2014. Thus, the AO added an amount of Rs. 4,91,69,153/- under s. 43CA of the IT Act.

  • Opposed to this addition, the assessee filed an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) (‘CIT(A)’), who deleted the addition. Aggrieved by the decision, the Revenue filed an appeal before the Tribunal, against which the assessee also filed a cross-objection. The assessee also filed another appeal seeking rectification in the order of the CIT(A) about the determination of the exact year of sale concerning the plots.

Held

  • The Tribunal dismissed the Revenue’s appeal and the assessee’s cross-objection while allowing the assessee’s appeal. The Tribunal held that the assessee was entitled to the benefit from s. 43CA(3) of the IT Act concerning plots booked in financial years 2009-10, 2010-11, and 2013-14. It also directed that the AO shall re-compute the profits, considering the complete details and registry regarding the sale of plots year-wise and accord the benefit of s. 43CA to the assessee.

  • The Tribunal relied on the Supreme Court (‘SC’) judgements in T.G Ashok Kumar v. Govindammal[^ii], and Brij Mohan v. Smt. Sugra Begum[^iii], which held that there is no legal requirement for an agreement or contract of sale of immovable property to be in writing, and that agreements can be oral agreements as well. Thus, the Tribunal rejected the discrepancies noted by the AO regarding the agreements. It further dismissed the AO’s apprehension towards the same witnesses signing over different years, noting that these witnesses were staff members of the assessee who were consistently available and working for the assessee during the relevant period.

  • Addressing the AO’s concerns about different parties making advance payments and registering the property, the Tribunal held that purchasers have the right to get the sale deed executed in their name or any other person’s name as per clause 4(b) of the sale agreement.

  • The Tribunal recognised that it is common business practice to change plots as per the availability and mutual agreement with customers. It addressed the issue of the non-appearance of advances in the balance sheet as of 31.03.2013, noting that the assessee firm had 199 plots, while Rajul Builder (proprietor Dilip Mehta) had 89 plots in the same Rajul City Colony. Both concerns booked plots at Rajul Builder’s office, and Dilip Mehta executed sale agreements for both. Advances initially recorded under Rajul Builder were transferred to Rajul Construction’s books when plots were changed, resulting in those advances not reflecting in the assessee’s balance sheet as of 31.03.2013. However, a reconciled plot-wise receipt of the advance and transfer details later reflected these transactions.

Our Analysis

This decision reaffirms the principle that law should not be turned into a tool of harassment. When assessing authorities fail to apply careful consideration in taxation cases, it leads to unnecessary, time-consuming litigation, which should be avoided given the already overburdened judicial system. This decision reinforced the taxpayer’s rights under s. 43CA(3) of the IT Act when conditions are met despite procedural irregularities. The decision also emphasised the recognition of business practices involving related firms and inter-company transactions during tax assessments.

All business and income factors should be thoroughly analysed at the time of assessment, and both independent and mutual consequences of actions should be considered. Concerns such as a staff member signing as a witness on multiple agreements alone should not be raised without other incriminating evidence. Similarly, common trade practices like changing plots and registering deeds with third parties should be recognised when examining facts before alleging tax evasion. Allegations should not be based on mere apprehension or hunch but on concrete facts. Otherwise, it only leads to a waste of time for all parties involved.

End Notes

[^i]: [2024] 159 taxmann.com 1261 (Jabalpur – Trib.) [dated: 03.01.2024]

[^ii]: (2010) 14 SCC 370

[^iii]: (1990) 4 SCC 147

Authored by Shivangi Bhardwaj at Metalegal Advocates. The views expressed are personal and do not constitute legal opinion.

More Insights

Cover image for the article: The Rise of Preventive Law and the Fear of Future Harm

24 Feb 2026

12

Min Read

The Rise of Preventive Law and the Fear of Future Harm

This essay examines where preventive law has overreached: in compliance frameworks divorced from the actual causes of contraventions, in the systematic reversal of the burden of proof, and most acutely, in the routine deployment of provisional attachment as a pre-adjudicatory punishment. The law designed to address the fear of harm has itself become an object of fear. Preventive law has emerged as the legislature's response to the complexity, scale, and pace of modern business activity and, in jurisdictions like India, as a scaffolding for laws that lack organic social consensus.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court: Retired Partner Still Liable Under NI Act if Statutory Formalities Are Not Followed

30 May 2025

4

Min Read

Supreme Court: Retired Partner Still Liable under NI Act if Statutory Formalities Are Not Followed

The Supreme Court, in Shivappa Reddy v. S. Srinivasan, has reaffirmed that partners retiring from a firm must strictly comply with statutory requirements under the Partnership Act to escape liability under the Negotiable Instruments Act. The Court set aside a High Court order quashing proceedings and emphasised that non-compliance with Section 72 obligations leaves retired partners exposed to criminal liability for dishonoured cheques.

Cover image for the article: Unifying the Framework & Strengthening Oversight: RBI’s Draft 2025 Directions on Co-Lending Arrangements Explained

01 May 2025

6

Min Read

Unifying the Framework & Strengthening Oversight: RBI’s Draft 2025 Directions on Co-Lending Arrangements Explained

The RBI has released the Draft Co-Lending Arrangements Directions, 2025, proposing a unified, market-enabling framework for regulated entities. The draft aims to streamline risk-sharing, pricing, and borrower protections across digital and traditional lending partnerships while replacing fragmented earlier guidelines. This explainer highlights key provisions, compliance expectations, and systemic implications.

Cover image for the article: RBI Issues Draft Directions on Non-Fund Based Credit Facilities: Bridging the Regulatory Gap

01 May 2025

6

Min Read

RBI Issues Draft Directions on Non-Fund Based Credit Facilities: Bridging the Regulatory Gap

The RBI has issued draft directions to regulate Non-Fund Based Credit Facilities such as guarantees, letters of credit, and partial credit enhancements. This write-up provides a detailed overview of the framework, its applicability to banks and NBFCs, the proposed exposure caps, and disclosure requirements, while highlighting the shift towards electronic guarantees and risk-based credit appraisals.

Stone columns and an ornate ceiling beneath a gridded skylight

01 May 2025

7

Min Read

RBI’s Draft Directions on Lending against Gold Collateral, 2025: A Step Toward Harmonised and Responsible Credit Practices

The RBI has released its draft 2025 Directions on lending against gold collateral, proposing a unified, principle-based framework for all regulated entities. These Directions aim to streamline prudential norms, standardise conduct practices, and strengthen consumer protection, while ensuring fair treatment and systemic stability in gold-backed credit markets.

Cover image for the article: Judicial Independence in Statutory Interpretation: US Supreme Court Restores Balance of Power in Administrative Law

28 Apr 2025

5

Min Read

Judicial Independence in Statutory Interpretation: US Supreme Court Restores Balance of Power in Administrative Law

the US Supreme Court has overruled the four-decade-old Chevron doctrine, reasserting that courts—not agencies—hold the ultimate authority to interpret ambiguous statutes. This decision reshapes administrative law, restoring judicial independence under Article III of the US Constitution and carrying persuasive relevance for jurisdictions like India that value a strict separation of powers.

Cover image for the article: SEBI Mandates Stricter Corporate Governance for High Value Debt Listed Entities (HVDLEs)

26 Apr 2025

3

Min Read

SEBI Mandates Stricter Corporate Governance for High Value Debt Listed Entities (HVDLEs)

SEBI’s 2025 amendments to the LODR Regulations introduce a new governance framework for High-Value Debt Listed Entities (HVDLEs) with ₹1,000 crore+ in listed NCDs. These norms align debt entities with equity governance standards, mandating board independence, committee oversight, and compliance timelines. This post unpacks key obligations, implications, and what debt-heavy issuers must do to remain compliant.

Cover image for the article: RBI Issues April 2025 Policy Statement; Proposes Co-Lending Framework for All Regulated Entities

17 Apr 2025

3

Min Read

RBI Issues April 2025 Policy Statement; Proposes Co-Lending Framework for All Regulated Entities

The RBI’s April 2025 Statement outlines key draft measures for co-lending expansion, stressed asset securitisation, harmonised gold loan norms, and UPI limit rationalisation. It further proposes a ‘theme-neutral’ fintech sandbox to foster continuous innovation. These reforms reflect the RBI’s proactive approach to market-based regulation, financial inclusion, and systemic resilience through stakeholder-driven policy development.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court: Cheque Bounce Complaint Quashed for Suppression of Material Facts

11 Apr 2025

4

Min Read

Supreme Court: Cheque Bounce Complaint Quashed for Suppression of Material Facts

The Supreme Court has quashed a cheque bounce complaint under Section 138 of the NI Act, citing deliberate suppression of critical defence documents by the complainant. The judgment reinforces that criminal prosecution cannot proceed where procedural fairness is compromised. This decision underscores the duty of complainants to disclose all material facts when initiating criminal process.

Stone columns and an ornate ceiling beneath a gridded skylight

09 Apr 2025

4

Min Read

SEBI Cracks down on Anchor Trading: Declares CNBC Anchor’s Conduct as Abuse of Market Privilege

SEBI has passed a landmark order against CNBC anchor Hemant Ghai for abusing media privilege to front-run stock tips for personal gain. By executing trades ahead of on-air recommendations via family accounts, and falsifying records, he violated market integrity norms. The order reaffirms SEBI’s stance on treating media-driven tip-offs as material non-public information under PFUTP regulations.

Cover image for the article: Government Revises MSME Classification Thresholds

09 Apr 2025

2

Min Read

Government Revises MSME Classification Thresholds

The Central Government has revised the investment and turnover thresholds for classifying Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises under the MSME Act, effective from 1 April 2025. The updated limits aim to broaden MSME coverage and enhance access to statutory benefits for a wider base of enterprises, subject to timely Udyam re-registration.

Cover image for the article: Constitutional Limits on Pre-Trial Incarceration: Delhi High Court Harmonizes Article 21 and Section 45 of the PMLA in Grant of Bail

30 Mar 2025

5

Min Read

Constitutional Limits on Pre-Trial Incarceration: Delhi High Court Harmonizes Article 21 and Section 45 of the PMLA in Grant of Bail

The Delhi High Court, in Christian James Michel v. Directorate of Enforcement, granted bail under PMLA on grounds of prolonged undertrial incarceration. The judgment highlights the constitutional imperative under Article 21 and harmonises it with the stringent bail provisions of Section 45 PMLA, reinforcing the jurisprudence against indefinite pre-trial detention in economic offences.

Cover image for the article: Appellate Tribunal Clarifies Penalty Standards and Compliance Duties under the SEBI’s Investment Adviser Regulations

27 Mar 2025

4

Min Read

Appellate Tribunal Clarifies Penalty Standards and Compliance Duties under the SEBI’s Investment Adviser Regulations

The SAT’s ruling in CapitalVia Global Research Ltd. v. SEBI offers valuable guidance on regulatory compliance for investment advisers under the SEBI framework. While upholding nine out of thirteen charges—including KYC failures, risk profiling lapses, and misleading disclosures—the Tribunal reduced the penalty from ₹1 crore to ₹70 lakhs, reaffirming the importance of proportionality in enforcement and the fiduciary obligations of advisory firms.

Cover image for the article: No Benami Without Ownership: Tribunal Rejects Attachment Based on Mere Agreement to Sell

20 Mar 2025

3

Min Read

No Benami without Ownership: Tribunal Rejects Attachment Based on Mere Agreement to Sell

The Appellate Tribunal under SAFEMA held that a mere agreement to sell, unsupported by a registered sale deed or actual possession, does not constitute a benami transaction under section 2(9)(A) of the Benami Act. In setting aside the provisional attachment, the Tribunal reaffirmed settled law that partial payments and unproven cash transfers do not suffice to trigger Benami Act consequences.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Clarifies Non-Executive Directors' Liability under the Negotiable Instruments Act

20 Mar 2025

4

Min Read

Supreme Court Clarifies Non-Executive Directors' Liability under the Negotiable Instruments Act

In K.S. Mehta v. Morgan Securities, the Supreme Court decisively addressed the vicarious liability of non-executive directors under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. Reinforcing strict construction principles, the Court quashed criminal proceedings against directors lacking active involvement, setting a clear precedent on the necessity of specific allegations for liability under Section 141.

Cover image for the article: SEBI’s 2025 Insider Trading Amendment: Expanding the UPSI Framework

19 Mar 2025

4

Min Read

SEBI’s 2025 Insider Trading Amendment: Expanding the UPSI Framework

SEBI’s 2025 amendment to the Insider Trading Regulations expands the definition of Unpublished Price Sensitive Information (UPSI), introduces new disclosure triggers, and streamlines compliance with structured data protocols. This regulatory update signals a decisive shift toward pre-emptive corporate transparency and robust market integrity safeguards.

Cover image for the article: IFSCA Mandates Cybersecurity & Resilience Norms for Regulated Entities in IFSC

17 Mar 2025

5

Min Read

IFSCA Mandates Cybersecurity & Resilience Norms for Regulated Entities in IFSC

The IFSCA has issued a comprehensive framework on cyber security and resilience for regulated entities operating in IFSC. These guidelines mandate robust governance, data protection, IT asset management, and incident reporting measures to counter escalating cyber threats. Regulated entities must adopt structured protocols, undergo annual audits, and manage third-party risk to ensure financial system stability.

Cover image for the article: Expanding Scope and Strengthening Enforcement: Significant Amendments in the CCI’s 2025 Recovery Regulations

04 Mar 2025

7

Min Read

Expanding Scope and Strengthening Enforcement: Significant Amendments in the CCI’s 2025 Recovery Regulations

CCI’s 2025 regulations overhaul penalty recovery with expanded scope, third-party liability, and legal heir accountability.

Cover image for the article: Sanction for Prosecution: Did the Supreme Court Overlook Deemed Sanction Under BNSS?

03 Mar 2025

5

Min Read

Sanction for Prosecution: Did the Supreme Court Overlook Deemed Sanction under BNSS?

Did the Supreme Court overlook BNSS’s deemed sanction provision? This analysis dissects the ruling's impact on public servant prosecutions.

Cover image for the article: A Comprehensive Overview of the EU’s AI Act: New Era in AI Governance – A Bold Step or a Regulatory Minefield?

28 Feb 2025

17

Min Read

A Comprehensive Overview of the EU’s AI Act: New Era in AI Governance – a Bold Step or a Regulatory Minefield?

An in-depth analysis of the EU's AI Act—its key provisions, risk-based approach, and global implications for AI governance.

Cover image for the article: Delhi High Court Reaffirms the Rajesh Agarwal Doctrine: Personal Hearing Must Precede Fraud Classification

28 Feb 2025

5

Min Read

Delhi High Court Reaffirms the Rajesh Agarwal Doctrine: Personal Hearing Must Precede Fraud Classification

In a pivotal ruling, the Delhi High Court has reaffirmed that borrowers are entitled to a personal hearing before their accounts are classified as fraud under the RBI Master Directions. Drawing upon the Supreme Court’s decision in SBI v. Rajesh Agarwal, the Court reinforced that procedural fairness and natural justice demand more than just written representation when civil consequences are involved.

Cover image for the article: RBI Introduces .bank.in and .fin.in to Strengthen Financial Security and Combat Fraud

13 Feb 2025

3

Min Read

RBI Introduces .Bank.in and .Fin.in to Strengthen Financial Security and Combat Fraud

RBI launches .bank.in for banks and plans .fin.in for NBFCs, enhancing cybersecurity and safeguarding users from financial fraud.

Cover image for the article: SEBI Strengthens Regulations for Persons Associated with the Securities Market

07 Feb 2025

4

Min Read

SEBI Strengthens Regulations for Persons Associated with the Securities Market

SEBI enforces stricter regulations on market associations, barring unauthorised investment advisory and misleading return claims.

Cover image for the article: RBI’s Revised Penalty & Compounding Framework Under the Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007: Strict Yet Balanced

04 Feb 2025

4

Min Read

RBI’s Revised Penalty & Compounding Framework under the Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007: Strict yet Balanced

RBI introduces a revised framework for penalties & compounding under the PSS Act, ensuring fair enforcement & compliance clarity.

Cover image for the article: Appellate Tribunal Holds Unexecuted Agreement Not Benami under Section 2(9)(A) of the Benami Act

30 Jan 2025

4

Min Read

Appellate Tribunal Holds Unexecuted Agreement Not Benami under Section 2(9)(a) of the Benami Act

In a significant ruling under the Benami Act, the SAFEMA Appellate Tribunal quashed a provisional attachment order where no sale deed was executed and ownership never transferred. The case reinforces that partial payment and mere intent to purchase do not amount to a benami transaction under s. 2(9)(A), absent legal title or possession.

Cover image for the article: [Delhi HC] Delayed Adjudication under Customs Act Results in Violation of Principles of Natural Justice

19 Jan 2025

4

Min Read

[Delhi HC] Delayed Adjudication under Customs Act Results in Violation of Principles of Natural Justice

A pivotal Delhi HC ruling underscores that prolonged adjudication delays in customs cases breach the principles of natural justice.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Clarifies Impact of Minor Discrepancies in Witness Testimony on Criminal Trials

17 Jan 2025

3

Min Read

Supreme Court Clarifies Impact of Minor Discrepancies in Witness Testimony on Criminal Trials

The SC clarifies that minor contradictions in witness testimony do not undermine the prosecution's case if overall evidence is reliable.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court: Sanction Orders and Procedural Justice in Anti-Corruption Trials

15 Jan 2025

3

Min Read

Supreme Court: Sanction Orders and Procedural Justice in Anti-Corruption Trials

The Supreme Court clarifies the validity of sanction orders under the Prevention of Corruption Act and their impact on justice and fairness.

Cover image for the article: Enhancing Credit Transparency in India: RBI Issues Comprehensive Guidelines for Credit Information Reporting

09 Jan 2025

6

Min Read

Enhancing Credit Transparency in India: RBI Issues Comprehensive Guidelines for Credit Information Reporting

RBI guidelines streamline credit reporting, enhancing transparency, data accuracy, and grievance redressal for borrowers and institutions.

Cover image for the article: The Ethical Compass of Legal Advocacy

06 Jan 2025

7

Min Read

The Ethical Compass of Legal Advocacy

Explore the role of ethics in legal advocacy, addressing key challenges lawyers face and why integrity is vital for justice and success.