Cover image for the article: SAFEMA Tribunal Clarifies Fiduciary Capacity under the Benami Act

22 Sep 2024

SAFEMA Tribunal Clarifies Fiduciary Capacity under the Benami Act

3

Min Read

Cover image for the article: SAFEMA Tribunal Clarifies Fiduciary Capacity under the Benami Act

22 Sep 2024

SAFEMA Tribunal Clarifies Fiduciary Capacity under the Benami Act

3

Min Read

Cover image for the article: SAFEMA Tribunal Clarifies Fiduciary Capacity under the Benami Act

22 Sep 2024

SAFEMA Tribunal Clarifies Fiduciary Capacity under the Benami Act

3

Min Read

Introduction

In the case of DCIT (BPU-1), Mumbai v. Jiten Pujari[i]*, *the Appellate Tribunal, under Smugglers and Foreign Exchange Manipulators (Forfeiture of Property) Act, 1976 (‘SAFEMA’), New Delhi (‘Tribunal’) addressed a significant issue involving the alleged holding of Rs. 9.94 crores across multiple bank lockers by employees of M/s Trigon Hotels and Resource Private Limited (‘Trigon Hotels’). The Tribunal had to assess whether the holdings were held in a benami capacity under the Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988 (‘Benami Act’) or fell under an exception due to the fiduciary relationship claimed by the beneficial owners.

Brief Facts

  • A search and survey were conducted on Trigon Hotels in July 2020 under ss. 132/133A of the Income-tax Act, 1961. During the search, cash amounting to Rs. 9.94 crores was discovered in four separate bank lockers held in the names of Jiten Pujari, Venkatesh Shenoy, and Siya Ram Pandey, employees of the alleged beneficial owners.

  • The sworn statements recorded from these individuals revealed that the cash belonged to two alleged beneficial owners, Ratan Kant Sharma and Shiv Shankar Sharma. These beneficial owners did not disown the cash and claimed it was kept in the lockers by their employees for safe custody.

  • Based on the sworn statements, the revenue department considered the cash to be part of a benami transaction and ordered the funds attached. However, the Adjudicating Authority (‘AA’) ruled against the attachment, holding that the cash was being held by the employees in a fiduciary capacity on behalf of their employers, falling under one of the exceptions to the definition of a benami transaction under s. 2(9)(A)(ii) of the Benami Act.

  • Dissatisfied with the AA’s refusal to confirm the attachment, the revenue department appealed before the Tribunal, arguing that the employees lacked the qualifications under the above-mentioned exception.

Held

  • The Tribunal dismissed the revenue’s appeal and upheld the AA's decision, confirming that the cash found in the lockers was not part of a benami transaction but held in a fiduciary capacity by the employees (‘alleged benamidars’) on behalf of their employers.

  • The Tribunal determined that the alleged benamidars were acting in a fiduciary capacity for the safe custody of cash on behalf of their employers, Ratan Kant Sharma and Shiv Shankar Sharma. Since the beneficial owners and the employees acknowledged the cash did not claim ownership, the situation fits within the exception provided under s. 2(9)(A)(ii).

  • The Tribunal relied on RBI v. Jayantilal N. Mistry (Supreme Court)[ii]*, *in which the Supreme Court outlined the scope of fiduciary relationships, including principles like the ‘No Conflict’ and ‘No Profit’ rules, which were deemed relevant to determining whether the funds were held for safekeeping without personal interest or gain.

  • The Tribunal also relied on Sri Marcel Martins v. M. Printer & Ors (Supreme Court)[iii]*, *where fiduciary capacity was extended to situations where trust and good faith are central to the relationship. This case was referenced to affirm that the employees’ role in safeguarding the cash on their employers' behalf met the fiduciary capacity criteria.

  • The Tribunal noted that none of the employees claimed ownership of the cash, and the beneficial owners did not disown the funds. Instead, the beneficial owners explicitly acknowledged the cash as theirs, stored for safekeeping with their employees.

  • The Tribunal further pointed out that the income tax assessments added the discovered amount to the income of the beneficial owners, reinforcing the fact that the funds belonged to them and were not hidden under a benami structure.

Our Analysis

The Tribunal’s decision in this case highlights the importance of distinguishing between actual benami transactions and legitimate fiduciary relationships. S. 2(9)(A)(ii) of the Benami Act provides an exception for property or assets held by individuals in a fiduciary capacity for the benefit of others. In this case, the Tribunal determined that the alleged benamidars were merely acting as custodians of the cash, holding it on behalf of their employers, Ratan Kant Sharma and Shiv Shankar Sharma.

The Tribunal’s interpretation followed the precedents of the Supreme Court, which explored the fiduciary duty to avoid conflicts, profit motives, and undue influence in relationships built on trust. It was careful to note that not all fiduciary relationships are exempt from scrutiny under the Benami Act. The fiduciary capacity must be genuine and cannot be used to shield illegal transactions or activities designed to conceal true ownership. The Tribunal made it clear that if there had been any evidence of the employees claiming ownership or using the funds for personal gain, the outcome may have been different. 

End Notes

[i] [2024] 166 taxmann.com 627 (SAFEMA - New Delhi).

[ii] (2016) 3 SCC 525.

[iii] (2012) 5 SCC 342.

Authored by Priyavansh Kaushik, Advocate at Metalegal Advocates. The views expressed are personal and do not constitute legal opinions.

Portrait of Priyavansh Kaushik
Portrait of Priyavansh Kaushik

AUTHORED BY

Associate

Associate

Associate

More Insights

Cover image for the article: Clean Before the Crime? Attachment of Properties Acquired Before the Commission of the Scheduled Offence under the PMLA

04 Nov 2025

15

Min Read

Clean before the Crime? Attachment of Properties Acquired before the Commission of the Scheduled Offence under the PMLA

Can property acquired before a crime be seized under the PMLA? This article examines how Indian courts have interpreted the concept of “proceeds of crime,” balancing enforcement power with constitutional safeguards, and compares global confiscation regimes to determine where the legal line truly lies.

Cover image for the article: No Conflict with the CrPC: Supreme Court Affirms Right to Fair Disclosure in PMLA Cases in Light of Reverse Burden on Accused

19 May 2025

10

Min Read

No Conflict with the CrPC: Supreme Court Affirms Right to Fair Disclosure in PMLA Cases in Light of Reverse Burden on Accused

In a landmark judgment, the Supreme Court affirmed that accused persons under the PMLA are entitled to access all documents seized or filed with the prosecution, regardless of reliance by the ED. The Court ruled this disclosure is essential to uphold Article 21 and harmonised CrPC procedures with PMLA's special framework, reinforcing procedural fairness even in economic offences involving reverse burden clauses.

Cover image for the article: [AT-PMLA] Property Attachment Upheld Following Illegal Call Interception at NSE

06 Apr 2025

4

Min Read

[AT-PMLA] Property Attachment Upheld Following Illegal Call Interception at NSE

The SAFEMA Appellate Tribunal has upheld the Enforcement Directorate’s attachment of iSec Services’ assets, following findings of unauthorised call interception at NSE. The Tribunal held that the actions amounted to cheating and money laundering, triggering provisions under the IPC and PMLA. The judgment underscores that fraudulent conduct disguised as formal contracts cannot escape penal consequences under Indian law.

Cover image for the article: [AT-PMLA] Upholds Attachment of Pre-Offence Acquired Property as 'Proceeds of Crime'

28 Mar 2025

3

Min Read

[AT-PMLA] Upholds Attachment of Pre-Offence Acquired Property as 'Proceeds of Crime'

The SAFEMA Appellate Tribunal upheld the ED's attachment of property acquired before the commission of a scheduled offence, holding it to be ‘proceeds of crime’ under PMLA. It ruled that the date of detection of laundering, not the original offence, governs applicability. The decision underscores key compliance principles around equivalent value attachment, retrospective prosecution, and statutory timelines impacted by COVID-19.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court: PMLA Is a Continuing Offence, Retrospectivity and Threshold Challenges Held Legally Unsustainable

26 Mar 2025

5

Min Read

Supreme Court: PMLA Is a Continuing Offence, Retrospectivity and Threshold Challenges Held Legally Unsustainable

SC upholds PMLA’s continuing offence doctrine, rejecting retrospective and threshold-based challenges to money laundering prosecutions.

Cover image for the article: AT-PMLA Clarifies Limits of Attachment: Seizure and Attachment Can Coexist, But Cannot Exceed Scheduled Offence Proceeds

05 Mar 2025

6

Min Read

AT-PMLA Clarifies Limits of Attachment: Seizure and Attachment Can Coexist, but Cannot Exceed Scheduled Offence Proceeds

The Appellate Tribunal under PMLA has clarified that while seizure and attachment can co-exist, the ED cannot attach property beyond the proceeds quantified in the scheduled offence. In Barik Biswas v. ED, the Tribunal reaffirmed key safeguards—procedural and proportionality-based—while reiterating that attachment must have a direct or equivalent nexus to the predicate offence under PMLA.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Reinforces Strict Bail Provisions Under PMLA: Strengthening Judicial Scrutiny & Statutory Compliance

25 Feb 2025

5

Min Read

Supreme Court Reinforces Strict Bail Provisions under PMLA: Strengthening Judicial Scrutiny & Statutory Compliance

The Supreme Court reinforces strict bail conditions under PMLA, setting a crucial precedent in Union of India v. Kanhaiya Prasad.

Cover image for the article: Non-Beneficial Joint Holder Spared Black Money Act Penalty: Tribunal Upholds Bona Fide Belief Principle

21 Feb 2025

4

Min Read

Non-Beneficial Joint Holder Spared Black Money Act Penalty: Tribunal Upholds Bona Fide Belief Principle

In a significant ruling, the ITAT Mumbai held that a non-beneficial joint holder of a foreign asset is not liable under the Black Money Act for non-disclosure, provided the omission was based on a bona fide belief and the asset was fully disclosed by the beneficial owner. This judgment reinforces judicial discretion in imposing penalties under Section 43 and underscores the importance of intent in tax compliance.

Cover image for the article: Bombay High Court Reaffirms: SEBI’s Regulatory Jurisdiction No Bar to Criminal Investigation in Financial Fraud Cases

13 Feb 2025

4

Min Read

Bombay High Court Reaffirms: SEBI’s Regulatory Jurisdiction No Bar to Criminal Investigation in Financial Fraud Cases

The Bombay High Court, in Shoaib Richie Sequeira v. State of Maharashtra, directed the formation of a CBI-led Special Investigation Team to probe a massive cross-border financial fraud. Despite compelling evidence, both the EOW and CBI had failed to act, citing SEBI's jurisdiction. The Court reaffirmed its constitutional authority to ensure fair and impartial investigations when agencies fail to fulfil their statutory responsibilities.

Cover image for the article: Karnataka High Court on PMLA Search & Seizure: Procedural Safeguards v. Investigative Powers

12 Feb 2025

5

Min Read

Karnataka High Court on PMLA Search & Seizure: Procedural Safeguards v. Investigative Powers

Karnataka HC rules on PMLA’s procedural safeguards, questioning the legality of search, seizure, and repeated summons by ED.

Cover image for the article: Bombay High Court: A Strong Stand Against the Misuse of Criminal Law in Contractual Disputes

07 Feb 2025

4

Min Read

Bombay High Court: A Strong Stand against the Misuse of Criminal Law in Contractual Disputes

Bombay HC quashes criminal charges in Rakesh Jain case, ruling that contractual disputes cannot be disguised as money laundering.

Cover image for the article: Property Attachment under PMLA: Appellate Tribunal Clarifies that Ownership and Possession Remain Unaltered

24 Jan 2025

4

Min Read

Property Attachment under PMLA: Appellate Tribunal Clarifies that Ownership and Possession Remain Unaltered

Can property attachment under PMLA affect ownership and possession? The Appellate Tribunal weighs in on this crucial legal question.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court: Economic Offences Cannot Be Quashed Even if a Settlement Exists Between the Parties

15 Jan 2025

3

Min Read

Supreme Court: Economic Offences Cannot Be Quashed Even if a Settlement Exists between the Parties

The SC reaffirms that economic offences cannot be quashed merely due to settlements, prioritising public accountability over compromise.

Cover image for the article: Due Process & Arbitrary Detention: Delhi HC Examines the Boundaries of Arrest Powers Under PMLA

18 Dec 2024

7

Min Read

Due Process & Arbitrary Detention: Delhi HC Examines the Boundaries of Arrest Powers under PMLA

Delhi HC rules on PMLA arrest safeguards, reaffirming procedural compliance, judicial oversight & necessity in financial crime cases.

Cover image for the article: [Punjab & Haryana HC] Special Courts, PMLA Must Exercise Judicial Independence, Not Act as Extensions of the Enforcement Directorate

15 Dec 2024

3

Min Read

[Punjab & Haryana HC] Special Courts, PMLA Must Exercise Judicial Independence, Not Act as Extensions of the Enforcement Directorate

The High Court ruled that PMLA courts must act independently and cannot permit ED custody without sound legal justification.

Cover image for the article: Delhi High Court: Fund Collection Alone Does Not Constitute Proceeds of Crime, Grants Bail

15 Dec 2024

4

Min Read

Delhi High Court: Fund Collection Alone Does Not Constitute Proceeds of Crime, Grants Bail

Delhi High Court grants bail under PMLA, ruling that fund collection without links to a scheduled offence isn't proceeds of crime.

Cover image for the article: Elevating Justice: The Imperative Role & Challenges of Special Courts in Economic Offences Prosecution

05 Dec 2024

12

Min Read

Elevating Justice: The Imperative Role & Challenges of Special Courts in Economic Offences Prosecution

Special Courts expedite justice in economic offences, addressing complex financial crimes with expertise while navigating systemic challenge

Illuminated domed courthouse building at night

02 Dec 2024

7

Min Read

Economic Offences under IPC: Challenges and Legal Evolution

Economic offences in India challenge traditional laws like the IPC, requiring modern frameworks to tackle evolving financial crimes.

Cover image for the article: Prolonged Incarceration Addressed: Calcutta HC Grants Bail in PMLA Case

01 Dec 2024

2

Min Read

Prolonged Incarceration Addressed: Calcutta HC Grants Bail in PMLA Case

Highlighting Article 21 of the Constitution, the Calcutta HC granted bail to a petitioner, balancing rights with alleged PMLA violations.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Clarifies the Scope of Section 195 of the CrPC While Preventing Erosion of Public Trust

29 Nov 2024

3

Min Read

Supreme Court Clarifies the Scope of Section 195 of the CrPC while Preventing Erosion of Public Trust

The Supreme Court reaffirms judicial accountability by clarifying procedural bars under Section 195 CrPC, ensuring trust in justice.

Cover image for the article: Jail is the Exception: Delhi High Court Reaffirms Article 21 in Granting Bail Under PMLA

29 Nov 2024

5

Min Read

Jail Is the Exception: Delhi High Court Reaffirms Article 21 in Granting Bail under PMLA

The Delhi HC grants bail under PMLA, stressing a. 21 rights and balancing stringent bail conditions with trial delays and liberty concerns.

Cover image for the article: Delhi High Court: Prosecution under the Black Money Act Not Contingent on Completion of Assessment

22 Nov 2024

4

Min Read

Delhi High Court: Prosecution under the Black Money Act Not Contingent on Completion of Assessment

Delhi HC affirms that prosecution under the Black Money Act can proceed independently of tax assessment proceedings under s. 10.

Cover image for the article: Intersection of CrPC, BNSS & PMLA: Supreme Court Reaffirms Sanction Requirements for Public Servants in PMLA Prosecutions

15 Nov 2024

4

Min Read

Intersection of CrPC, BNSS & PMLA: Supreme Court Reaffirms Sanction Requirements for Public Servants in PMLA Prosecutions

The SC reinforces procedural safeguards under CrPC for PMLA cases, ensuring sanctions for public servants align with official duties.

Cover image for the article: The Role of Forensic Auditing in Uncovering Financial Frauds: An Overview within the Indian Legal Framework

28 Oct 2024

16

Min Read

The Role of Forensic Auditing in Uncovering Financial Frauds: An Overview within the Indian Legal Framework

Forensic auditing is crucial in detecting corporate fraud in India, supporting legal cases and strengthening corporate governance.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Grants Bail in PMLA Case Due to Absence of Scheduled Offence

13 Oct 2024

2

Min Read

Supreme Court Grants Bail in PMLA Case Due to Absence of Scheduled Offence

The Supreme Court granted bail in a PMLA case, citing the absence of a scheduled offence at the time of filing the complaint or chargesheet.

Cover image for the article: Tribunal Upholds Strict Penalties for Non-Compliance in AML Reporting, Emphasizing Zero Tolerance for Delayed or Missed CTRs Under PMLA

02 Oct 2024

5

Min Read

Tribunal Upholds Strict Penalties for Non-Compliance in AML Reporting, Emphasizing Zero Tolerance for Delayed or Missed CTRs under PMLA

The Tribunal upheld stringent penalties for a bank's failure to report cash transactions under PMLA, reinforcing strict AML compliance.

Cover image for the article: Scope of Asset Freezing: Tribunal Upholds ED’s Authority Under PMLA in RAP Events Case

22 Sep 2024

4

Min Read

Scope of Asset Freezing: Tribunal Upholds ED’s Authority under PMLA in RAP Events Case

Tribunal upholds ED's freezing of accounts under PMLA, affirming a strict approach to proceeds of crime in financial investigations.

Cover image for the article: FEMA Compounding Rules 2024: Key Amendments and Non-Compoundable Offences

20 Sep 2024

3

Min Read

FEMA Compounding Rules 2024: Key Amendments and Non-Compoundable Offences

Explore key changes in FEMA Rules 2024, including new compounding guidelines and introduction of non-compoundable offences.

Cover image for the article: PMLA v. CrPC: Supreme Court Clarifies Scope of ED's Summons Under PMLA Over CrPC Safeguards

19 Sep 2024

4

Min Read

PMLA v. CrPC: Supreme Court Clarifies Scope of ED's Summons under PMLA over CrPC Safeguards

SC affirms ED's powers under PMLA exceed CrPC limits, ensuring robust scrutiny without regional or gender constraints.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Strikes a Balance Between Liberty & Law: Upholds Arrest Legality but Grants Bail

19 Sep 2024

6

Min Read

Supreme Court Strikes a Balance between Liberty & Law: Upholds Arrest Legality but Grants Bail

The Supreme Court reevaluates arrest norms and grants bail, affirming constitutional rights amid legal complexities.