Cover image for the article: NCLAT Clarifies that Accounting Set-Offs May Constitute Preferential Transactions under s. 43 of the IBC

05 Apr 2026

NCLAT Clarifies that Accounting Set-Offs May Constitute Preferential Transactions under S. 43 of the IBC

4

Min Read

Cover image for the article: NCLAT Clarifies that Accounting Set-Offs May Constitute Preferential Transactions under s. 43 of the IBC

05 Apr 2026

NCLAT Clarifies that Accounting Set-Offs May Constitute Preferential Transactions under S. 43 of the IBC

4

Min Read

Cover image for the article: NCLAT Clarifies that Accounting Set-Offs May Constitute Preferential Transactions under s. 43 of the IBC

05 Apr 2026

NCLAT Clarifies that Accounting Set-Offs May Constitute Preferential Transactions under S. 43 of the IBC

4

Min Read

Introduction

Preferential transactions under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (‘IBC’), often raise complex questions where commercial arrangements between related parties intersect with the principle of equitable distribution among creditors. The issue becomes particularly nuanced when such transactions are structured through accounting adjustments rather than actual fund transfers, raising doubts as to whether they fall within the ambit of 'transfer of property' under s. 43. The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (‘NCLAT’), in Atul Babulal Prajapati & Anr. v. Suhas Dinkar Bhattbhatt & Ors.[^i], engages with this question by examining whether accounting adjustments that extinguish the corporate debtor's (‘CD’) receivables in favour of related parties constitute preferential transactions, and clarifies that actual fund transfer is not necessary for invoking s. 43 where such transactions result in the extinguishment of receivables.

Brief Facts

  • The CD, WSH Pvt. Ltd., promoted by the Appellants (suspended directors/promoters), was admitted into the corporate insolvency resolution process (‘CIRP’) on 01.02.2021, pursuant to which a forensic audit was conducted for FY 2018-2019 and 2019-2020.

  • The forensic audit revealed that the  CD had offset receivables from Wholesale Hub LLP against payables due to the Appellant’s proprietorship concern, without routing through the CD’s bank account, resulting in diversion and extinguishment of receivables, amounting to Rs. 2,00,50,141/-. The adjustment was effected through accounting entries dated 30.06.2019, extinguishing the CD’s receivable.

  • The resolution professional filed I.A. No. 556 of 2021 under ss. 43, 45, and 66 of the IBC seeking avoidance of various transactions, including preferential transactions.

  • The National Company Law Tribunal (‘NCLT’), by order dated 01.10.2024, partially allowed the application, holding the aforesaid transaction to be preferential and directing repayment of Rs. 2,00,50,000/-, while rejecting other reliefs.

  • The said order was challenged before the NCLAT, wherein it was contended that the impugned transaction was merely an accounting adjustment without any actual transfer of funds, did not confer any preferential benefit, and could not be brought within the ambit of s. 43 of the IBC, including on the grounds that it fell within the ordinary course of business and outside the relevant look-back period.

Held

  • The NCLAT upheld the findings of the NCLT and held that the Appellant, being a director and person in control of multiple entities, including Wholesale Hub LLP and his proprietorship concern, squarely falls within the ambit of a ‘related party’ under s. 5(24) of the IBC.

  • The NCLAT observed that the impugned transaction dated 30.06.2019, as reflected in the ledger accounts and confirmed by the forensic audit, falls within the two-year look-back period preceding the insolvency commencement date, thereby satisfying the requirement under s. 43(4) of the IBC.

  • The NCLAT rejected the contention that no 'transfer' had taken place and held that a transfer under s. 43 is not confined to the actual movement of funds. It was observed that the extinguishment of receivables through accounting set-off entries constitutes a transfer of property or an interest thereof within the meaning of s. 43(2)(a).

  • The Tribunal further clarified that extinguishment or reduction of an enforceable receivable constitutes transfer of an ‘interest in property’ under s. 43(2)(a).

  • The NCLAT further held that the transaction satisfied both limbs of s. 43(2), since the adjustment was in respect of an antecedent liability, and had the effect of placing the Appellant in a more beneficial position than other creditors, particularly when several creditors remained unpaid.

  • The NCLAT noted that such an adjustment resulted in the extinguishment of a valuable receivable of the CD, thereby reducing the asset pool available for distribution under s. 53 of the IBC and prejudicing the interests of other creditors.

  • The NCLAT also observed that such conduct, involving diversion of receivables for the benefit of a related party, operated to the detriment of creditors and attracted scrutiny not only under s. 43, but also in the context of ss. 66(1) and 66(2) of the IBC.

  • In view of the above, the NCLAT held that the impugned transaction was rightly classified as a preferential transaction, found no infirmity in the order of the NCLT, and accordingly dismissed the appeal.

Our Analysis

The judgment reinforces and extends the existing interpretation of avoidance powers under the IBC, particularly the ‘substance over form’ doctrine. The NCLAT’s primary contribution in this ruling lies in its rejection of the so-called 'physicality defence,' wherein the Appellants contended that the absence of a cash movement through banking channels precluded a 'transfer of property' under s. 43. By holding that the extinguishment of a receivable through a book adjustment constitutes a transfer of an interest in property, the Tribunal clarifies the scope of transactions that may fall within avoidance jurisdiction, including 'paper-only' transactions.

This interpretation aligns with the definition of ‘property’ under s. 3(27) of the IBC, which includes actionable claims. Accordingly, the extinguishment of a CD’s receivable through such accounting adjustments results in a reduction of the asset pool available for distribution among creditors. Where such an adjustment operates in favour of a related party, it may confer a preferential advantage by placing that party in a more beneficial position than other creditors, subject to the requirements of s. 43 of the IBC.

The ruling further reflects that the determination of a preferential transaction turns on its effect on the creditor pool, rather than the form or structure of the transaction, thereby aligning the interpretation of s. 43 with its core objective of equitable distribution.

Further, the judgment provides a necessary refinement of the ‘ordinary course of business’ exception under s. 43(3). The NCLAT indicates that the defence requires more than demonstrating that the underlying trade was routine; the method of settlement must also conform to established commercial and financial practices. In the present case, the multilateral set-off between entities under common control, lacking formal corporate authorisation and bypassing banking channels, was rightly treated as an extraordinary arrangement rather than a routine commercial transaction.

This approach signals that internal accounting adjustments between related entities during the look-back period are likely to invite heightened scrutiny, particularly where they impact the asset pool of the corporate debtor. The Tribunal’s observations in the context of s. 66 further underscores that such transactions, if structured to the detriment of creditors, may attract additional consequences under the IBC’s anti-avoidance framework.

End Notes

[^i]: Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 2273 of 2024 dated 25.03.2026

Authored by the Editorial Board at Metalegal Advocates. Views expressed are strictly personal and do not constitute legal opinion.

More Insights

Stone columns and an ornate ceiling beneath a gridded skylight

24 Jul 2026

10

Min Read

‘Shylockian’ Lending Is ‘Squeezing of Blood’: NCLT Moves beyond Debt & Default to Reject a Section 7 Application

In a rare departure from the conventional debt-and-default enquiry under section 7 of the IBC, the NCLT, Kochi Bench rejected the financial creditors' petition after characterizing the underlying arrangement as a ‘Shylockian system’ of lending. This article discusses Shylockian lending and examines the strength of the Tribunal's focus on the economic substance of the transaction against established legal principles governing admission under section 7 of the IBC.

Cover image for the article: Claim Admission is not Debt Acknowledgement: Supreme Court on RP’s Role & Limitation under the IBC

22 Jun 2026

8

Min Read

Claim Admission Is Not Debt Acknowledgement: Supreme Court on RP’s Role & Limitation under the IBC

Can admission of a claim by a Resolution Professional extend limitation under section 18 of the Limitation Act? In Shankar Khandelwal v. Omkara Asset Reconstruction Pvt. Ltd., the Supreme Court answered this question in the negative, holding that claim admission during CIRP is merely a statutory claim-verification process and not an acknowledgement of debt. The ruling clarifies the RP’s non-adjudicatory role and reinforces important principles governing limitation under the IBC.

Cover image for the article: A One-Stop Shop for the IBC Amendment Bill of 2025 - Legal Update & Analysis of the IBC’s Next Turning Point

19 Dec 2025

18

Min Read

A One-Stop Shop for the IBC Amendment Bill of 2025 - Legal Update & Analysis of the IBC’s Next Turning Point

The IBC (Amendment) Bill, 2025 marks a structural recalibration of India’s insolvency regime. Beyond procedural changes, it reshapes when insolvency becomes collective, how decisional authority is exercised, and what finality means post-resolution. This Insight examines the Bill through the normative foundations of insolvency law, asking whether speed and certainty can be pursued without eroding inclusion, equality, and legitimacy.

Cover image for the article: Authority to Represent & Vakalatnamas: Juridical Foundations and Practical Issues

24 Sep 2025

6

Min Read

Authority to Represent & Vakalatnamas: Juridical Foundations and Practical Issues

In litigation practice, the authority of an advocate to act is often taken for granted, with vakalatnamas and authority letters treated as routine paperwork. Yet beneath this apparent formality lies a dense body of law that determines the very legitimacy of representation. Questions of who may sign, how consent is proved, and whether a scanned signature suffices are not clerical details: they cut to the root of agency, evidence, and procedure.

Cover image for the article: RBI’s 2024 Directions on Wilful & Large Defaulters: A Comprehensive Framework for Transparent Classification, Treatment & Reporting

04 Aug 2024

6

Min Read

RBI’s 2024 Directions on Wilful & Large Defaulters: A Comprehensive Framework for Transparent Classification, Treatment & Reporting

RBI's 2024 rules enhance financial system integrity by tightening wilful defaulter identification and treatment.

Cover image for the article: A New Dawn for MSMEs: The IBC's Strategic Insolvency Framework

20 Jul 2024

11

Min Read

A New Dawn for MSMEs: The IBC's Strategic Insolvency Framework

Introduction The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code ( ‘IBC’ ), enacted in India in 2016, provides a comprehensive framework for resolving...

Cover image for the article: [NCLAT] Affirms IBC's Overriding Effect Over SARFAESI and RDDBFI Acts in Insolvency Proceedings

10 Jul 2024

4

Min Read

[NCLAT] Affirms IBC's Overriding Effect over SARFAESI and RDDBFI Acts in Insolvency Proceedings

NCLAT upholds IBC's supremacy in insolvency resolutions, impacting SARFAESI and RDDBFI proceedings

Cover image for the article: Unstamped Agreement Does Not Nullify Operational Debt Claim under the IBC: NCLAT

31 May 2024

3

Min Read

Unstamped Agreement Does Not Nullify Operational Debt Claim under the IBC: NCLAT

NCLAT ruling safeguards OCs' rights, affirming unstamped contracts still hold under IBC.

Cover image for the article: Third-party Assets not liable to be included in the CIRP Process initiated against the Corporate Debtor

02 May 2024

3

Min Read

Third-Party Assets Not Liable to Be Included in the CIRP Process Initiated against the Corporate Debtor

NCLAT rules that third-party assets in possession of a corporate debtor can't be included in CIRP without a valid contract.

Cover image for the article: Bank’s Oversight: Supreme Court Upholds Procedural Compliance in Auction Sales under the SARFAESI Act

28 Apr 2024

3

Min Read

Bank’s Oversight: Supreme Court Upholds Procedural Compliance in Auction Sales under the SARFAESI Act

SC affirms the need for strict procedural compliance in bank auctions, reinstates tenants, and mandates interest on returns.

Cover image for the article: NCLAT Dismisses the Application Filed Under S. 9 of the IBC: Pre-Existing Dispute at the Forefront

17 Mar 2024

3

Min Read

NCLAT Dismisses the Application Filed under S. 9 of the IBC: Pre-Existing Dispute at the Forefront

NCLAT rules on the importance of resolving disputes before filing under s. 9 of the IBC.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Reiterates: No Withdrawal is Permitted for Resolution Plans Once Approved by the Committee of Creditors

13 Mar 2024

3

Min Read

Supreme Court Reiterates: No Withdrawal Is Permitted for Resolution Plans Once Approved by the Committee of Creditors

SC enforces strict adherence to CoC-approved Plans, barring unilateral withdrawals except in cases of fraud.

Cover image for the article: Beyond Corporate Dissolution: Ensuring Directorial Accountability for Company Debts

06 Mar 2024

2

Min Read

Beyond Corporate Dissolution: Ensuring Directorial Accountability for Company Debts

Introduction In the case of Biman Bangladesh Airlines Limited v. Kuka Travels Private Ltd. [i] , the High Court of Calcutta (' HC' )...

Cover image for the article: Understanding the Impact of the IBBI (Bankruptcy Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) (Amendment) Regulations, 2024

06 Feb 2024

2

Min Read

Understanding the Impact of the IBBI (Bankruptcy Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) (Amendment) Regulations, 2024

Introduction The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India ( ‘IBBI’ ) has enacted significant amendments through the IBBI (Bankruptcy...

Cover image for the article: SARFAESI Act: HC Refuses to Entertain Disputes Under SARFAESI on Grounds of Alternate Remedy

28 Dec 2023

3

Min Read

SARFAESI Act: HC Refuses to Entertain Disputes under SARFAESI on Grounds of Alternate Remedy

High Court of Punjab & Haryana emphasises SARFAESI’s self-contained remedies, limiting intervention to only unique legal queries.

Cover image for the article: Madras High Court Explores the Boundaries of Valuation Report Sharing by Resolution Professionals

27 Dec 2023

3

Min Read

Madras High Court Explores the Boundaries of Valuation Report Sharing by Resolution Professionals

Discover how Madras HC addresses unauthorised VR sharing by RPs in liquidation cases, emphasising strict IBBI guidelines.

Cover image for the article: [NCLT] Amounts Payable Under Successful Resolution Plan Do Not Constitute Financial Debt

27 Dec 2023

3

Min Read

[NCLT] Amounts Payable under Successful Resolution Plan Do Not Constitute Financial Debt

NCLT rules that plan payments are not 'financial debt' under IBC s.7.

Cover image for the article: IBBI issues the Insolvency Professionals Panel Guidelines, 2023

21 Dec 2023

3

Min Read

IBBI Issues the Insolvency Professionals Panel Guidelines, 2023

Introduction In a proactive move to enhance the efficiency of insolvency resolution and liquidation proceedings, the Insolvency and...

Cover image for the article: The Tribunal Upholds the Validity of Investigations Under S. 213 of the Companies Act, 2013 During CIRP and Liquidation Proceedings

21 Dec 2023

3

Min Read

The Tribunal Upholds the Validity of Investigations under S. 213 of the Companies Act, 2013 During CIRP and Liquidation Proceedings

NCLT directs probe into Vikram Structures for illegal sales exceeding 243,037 sq. ft., misappropriating Rs. 136.5 crores.

Cover image for the article: Karnataka High Court Quashes CoC Resolutions Over Procedural Irregularities

30 Nov 2023

3

Min Read

Karnataka High Court Quashes CoC Resolutions over Procedural Irregularities

Karnataka HC enforces fairness in insolvency, invalidating a CoC decision due to notice flaws

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Upholds Constitutional Validity of Ss. 95 to 100 of the IBC Provisions Relating to Personal Guarantors

23 Nov 2023

4

Min Read

Supreme Court Upholds Constitutional Validity of Ss. 95 to 100 of the IBC Provisions Relating to Personal Guarantors

Landmark SC ruling affirms key IBC sections, ensuring fair insolvency processes for personal guarantors.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court’s Landmark Decision: Equal Treatment to Government’s Secured Claims in IBC Cases

05 Nov 2023

3

Min Read

Supreme Court’s Landmark Decision: Equal Treatment to Government’s Secured Claims in IBC Cases

Introduction Recently in the case of Sanjay Kumar Agarwal v. State Tax Officer & Anr. , the Supreme Court of India ( ‘SC’ ) dismissed a batch of review petitions filed against the case of Rainbow Papers Limited

Cover image for the article: [SC] Property not exempt under SARFAESI Act if merely shown as agricultural land in revenue records

20 Jan 2023

4

Min Read

[SC] Property Not Exempt under SARFAESI Act if Merely Shown as Agricultural Land in Revenue Records

The Supreme Court has recently held in K Sreedhar v Raus Construction Pvt Ltd 2023 SCC OnLine SC 13 that merely because certain...

Cover image for the article: MCA proposes key changes to IBC, seeks public comments

19 Jan 2023

4

Min Read

MCA Proposes Key Changes to IBC, Seeks Public Comments

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) has, vide its notice dated 18th January 2023, proposed key amendments to the Insolvency and...