Cover image for the article: Madras High Court Explores the Boundaries of Valuation Report Sharing by Resolution Professionals

27 Dec 2023

Madras High Court Explores the Boundaries of Valuation Report Sharing by Resolution Professionals

3

Min Read

Cover image for the article: Madras High Court Explores the Boundaries of Valuation Report Sharing by Resolution Professionals

27 Dec 2023

Madras High Court Explores the Boundaries of Valuation Report Sharing by Resolution Professionals

3

Min Read

Cover image for the article: Madras High Court Explores the Boundaries of Valuation Report Sharing by Resolution Professionals

27 Dec 2023

Madras High Court Explores the Boundaries of Valuation Report Sharing by Resolution Professionals

3

Min Read

Introduction

In the case, Ad. (CA) V. Venkata Siva Kumar v. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India & Ors.[^i] involves, the petitioner, a resolution professional (‘RP’) facing a show-cause notice (‘SCN’) from the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (‘IBBI’) alleging unauthorised sharing of valuation reports (‘VRs’) during the liquidation. The petitioner filed the writ petition (‘WP’) under a. 226 of the Constitution of India, 1949 (‘Constitution’) before the High Court of Madras (‘HC’), which affirmed the suspension of the RP’s authorisation during the pendency of disciplinary investigations, albeit allowing him an opportunity to defend himself during the inquiry.

Brief Facts

  • The petitioner faced the SCN from the IBBI under s. 219 of the IBC read with reg. 11 and 12 of the IBBI (Inspection and Investigation) Regulations, 2017. The allegation was that the petitioner, in his capacity as the liquidator for M/s Jeypore Sugar Limited, improperly shared VRs with potential scheme proponents, leading to uniform pricing submissions.

  • The SCN resulted in the automatic suspension of the Authorisation for Assignment (‘AFA’) of the RP under reg. 23A of the Model Byelaws and Governing Board of Insolvency Professional Agencies Regulations, 2016. The petitioner challenged the SCN.

  • The petitioner contended that the IBBI lacked authority over a liquidator appointed by the National Company Law Tribunal (‘NCLT’) and challenged the SCN’s validity on multiple grounds, including mala fide intent, dismissal of the complainant’s case, and ongoing proceedings before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (‘NCLAT’).

  • The petitioner argued that sharing pertinent information with stakeholders is a liquidator’s duty, as per s. 230 of the Companies Act, 2013. The petitioner also questioned the suspension of the AFA without a hearing.

  • The respondent argued that the IBBI has the authority under s. 218 of the IBC to initiate action based on information from any source, not limited to complaints under s. 217 of the IBC. They contended that the petitioner’s defence, raised prematurely, should be presented before the IBBI, challenging the jurisdiction to issue the SCN. The petitioner’s reliance on s. 217 of the IBC was countered, stating that s. 218 of the IBC operated independently and is not bound by decisions under s. 204 of the IBC. The HC, invoking a. 226 of the Constitution, could not examine the defence to the SCN, as the IBBI was the proper forum to consider materials and defences raised by the petitioner. 

Held

  • The HC upheld the automatic suspension during disciplinary proceedings, thus, dismissing the WP. The HC primarily focused on the legal merits of the case rather than personal animosities between the parties. It highlighted the IBC’s scheme, emphasising that sharing the VRs of a corporate debtor (‘CD’) is not explicitly authorised, especially during liquidation.

  • The HC also highlighted that prima facie, the petitioner admitted to sharing the VRs gave grounds for the IBBI to issue the SCN. The sequence of events was also taken into consideration starting from the appointment of the petitioner as RP, the failure of the corporate insolvency resolution process, leading to the liquidation proceedings, followed by the complaints against the petitioner.
    The HC further concluded that, once the petitioner becomes a liquidator, the role of the Indian Institute of Insolvency Professionals of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (‘IIIP/ICAI’) ceases. However, the HC lastly observed that the petitioner retained the liberty to present his defence during the disciplinary inquiry.

Analysis

The HC, in its decision, emphasises the critical framework within the IBC regarding the lack of explicit authorisation for sharing a CD’s VRs during the liquidation phase. It notes that upon assuming the role of a liquidator, the petitioner is primarily governed by the IBBI regulations, signifying a significant shift in regulatory focus from the IIIP/ICAI guidelines. This change reflects the HC’s dedication to clearly delineating the roles and responsibilities in insolvency proceedings, thereby ensuring a precise and unambiguous framework.

This decision also clarifies the overlap between the IBC and the Companies Act, 2013 in liquidation proceedings and upholds the IBBI’s authority to initiate disciplinary action despite IIIP/ICAI’s rejection of the complaint.

End Note

[^i]: [2024] 158 taxmann.com 217 (Madras) dated 22.12.2023.

Authored by Shivam Mishra at Metalegal Advocates. The views expressed are personal and do not constitute legal opinion.

Portrait of Shivam Mishra
Portrait of Shivam Mishra

AUTHORED BY

Associate

Associate

Associate

More Insights

Stone columns and an ornate ceiling beneath a gridded skylight

24 Jul 2026

10

Min Read

‘Shylockian’ Lending Is ‘Squeezing of Blood’: NCLT Moves beyond Debt & Default to Reject a Section 7 Application

In a rare departure from the conventional debt-and-default enquiry under section 7 of the IBC, the NCLT, Kochi Bench rejected the financial creditors' petition after characterizing the underlying arrangement as a ‘Shylockian system’ of lending. This article discusses Shylockian lending and examines the strength of the Tribunal's focus on the economic substance of the transaction against established legal principles governing admission under section 7 of the IBC.

Cover image for the article: Claim Admission is not Debt Acknowledgement: Supreme Court on RP’s Role & Limitation under the IBC

22 Jun 2026

8

Min Read

Claim Admission Is Not Debt Acknowledgement: Supreme Court on RP’s Role & Limitation under the IBC

Can admission of a claim by a Resolution Professional extend limitation under section 18 of the Limitation Act? In Shankar Khandelwal v. Omkara Asset Reconstruction Pvt. Ltd., the Supreme Court answered this question in the negative, holding that claim admission during CIRP is merely a statutory claim-verification process and not an acknowledgement of debt. The ruling clarifies the RP’s non-adjudicatory role and reinforces important principles governing limitation under the IBC.

Cover image for the article: NCLAT Clarifies that Accounting Set-Offs May Constitute Preferential Transactions under s. 43 of the IBC

05 Apr 2026

4

Min Read

NCLAT Clarifies that Accounting Set-Offs May Constitute Preferential Transactions under S. 43 of the IBC

The NCLAT clarifies that accounting set-offs may constitute preferential transactions under s. 43 of the IBC where they result in the extinguishment of receivables and confer a benefit on related parties. The ruling reinforces a substance-over-form approach and underscores that even non-cash adjustments impacting the asset pool of the corporate debtor are subject to avoidance.

Cover image for the article: A One-Stop Shop for the IBC Amendment Bill of 2025 - Legal Update & Analysis of the IBC’s Next Turning Point

19 Dec 2025

18

Min Read

A One-Stop Shop for the IBC Amendment Bill of 2025 - Legal Update & Analysis of the IBC’s Next Turning Point

The IBC (Amendment) Bill, 2025 marks a structural recalibration of India’s insolvency regime. Beyond procedural changes, it reshapes when insolvency becomes collective, how decisional authority is exercised, and what finality means post-resolution. This Insight examines the Bill through the normative foundations of insolvency law, asking whether speed and certainty can be pursued without eroding inclusion, equality, and legitimacy.

Cover image for the article: Authority to Represent & Vakalatnamas: Juridical Foundations and Practical Issues

24 Sep 2025

6

Min Read

Authority to Represent & Vakalatnamas: Juridical Foundations and Practical Issues

In litigation practice, the authority of an advocate to act is often taken for granted, with vakalatnamas and authority letters treated as routine paperwork. Yet beneath this apparent formality lies a dense body of law that determines the very legitimacy of representation. Questions of who may sign, how consent is proved, and whether a scanned signature suffices are not clerical details: they cut to the root of agency, evidence, and procedure.

Cover image for the article: RBI’s 2024 Directions on Wilful & Large Defaulters: A Comprehensive Framework for Transparent Classification, Treatment & Reporting

04 Aug 2024

6

Min Read

RBI’s 2024 Directions on Wilful & Large Defaulters: A Comprehensive Framework for Transparent Classification, Treatment & Reporting

RBI's 2024 rules enhance financial system integrity by tightening wilful defaulter identification and treatment.

Cover image for the article: A New Dawn for MSMEs: The IBC's Strategic Insolvency Framework

20 Jul 2024

11

Min Read

A New Dawn for MSMEs: The IBC's Strategic Insolvency Framework

Introduction The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code ( ‘IBC’ ), enacted in India in 2016, provides a comprehensive framework for resolving...

Cover image for the article: [NCLAT] Affirms IBC's Overriding Effect Over SARFAESI and RDDBFI Acts in Insolvency Proceedings

10 Jul 2024

4

Min Read

[NCLAT] Affirms IBC's Overriding Effect over SARFAESI and RDDBFI Acts in Insolvency Proceedings

NCLAT upholds IBC's supremacy in insolvency resolutions, impacting SARFAESI and RDDBFI proceedings

Cover image for the article: Unstamped Agreement Does Not Nullify Operational Debt Claim under the IBC: NCLAT

31 May 2024

3

Min Read

Unstamped Agreement Does Not Nullify Operational Debt Claim under the IBC: NCLAT

NCLAT ruling safeguards OCs' rights, affirming unstamped contracts still hold under IBC.

Cover image for the article: Third-party Assets not liable to be included in the CIRP Process initiated against the Corporate Debtor

02 May 2024

3

Min Read

Third-Party Assets Not Liable to Be Included in the CIRP Process Initiated against the Corporate Debtor

NCLAT rules that third-party assets in possession of a corporate debtor can't be included in CIRP without a valid contract.

Cover image for the article: Bank’s Oversight: Supreme Court Upholds Procedural Compliance in Auction Sales under the SARFAESI Act

28 Apr 2024

3

Min Read

Bank’s Oversight: Supreme Court Upholds Procedural Compliance in Auction Sales under the SARFAESI Act

SC affirms the need for strict procedural compliance in bank auctions, reinstates tenants, and mandates interest on returns.

Cover image for the article: NCLAT Dismisses the Application Filed Under S. 9 of the IBC: Pre-Existing Dispute at the Forefront

17 Mar 2024

3

Min Read

NCLAT Dismisses the Application Filed under S. 9 of the IBC: Pre-Existing Dispute at the Forefront

NCLAT rules on the importance of resolving disputes before filing under s. 9 of the IBC.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Reiterates: No Withdrawal is Permitted for Resolution Plans Once Approved by the Committee of Creditors

13 Mar 2024

3

Min Read

Supreme Court Reiterates: No Withdrawal Is Permitted for Resolution Plans Once Approved by the Committee of Creditors

SC enforces strict adherence to CoC-approved Plans, barring unilateral withdrawals except in cases of fraud.

Cover image for the article: Beyond Corporate Dissolution: Ensuring Directorial Accountability for Company Debts

06 Mar 2024

2

Min Read

Beyond Corporate Dissolution: Ensuring Directorial Accountability for Company Debts

Introduction In the case of Biman Bangladesh Airlines Limited v. Kuka Travels Private Ltd. [i] , the High Court of Calcutta (' HC' )...

Cover image for the article: Understanding the Impact of the IBBI (Bankruptcy Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) (Amendment) Regulations, 2024

06 Feb 2024

2

Min Read

Understanding the Impact of the IBBI (Bankruptcy Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) (Amendment) Regulations, 2024

Introduction The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India ( ‘IBBI’ ) has enacted significant amendments through the IBBI (Bankruptcy...

Cover image for the article: SARFAESI Act: HC Refuses to Entertain Disputes Under SARFAESI on Grounds of Alternate Remedy

28 Dec 2023

3

Min Read

SARFAESI Act: HC Refuses to Entertain Disputes under SARFAESI on Grounds of Alternate Remedy

High Court of Punjab & Haryana emphasises SARFAESI’s self-contained remedies, limiting intervention to only unique legal queries.

Cover image for the article: [NCLT] Amounts Payable Under Successful Resolution Plan Do Not Constitute Financial Debt

27 Dec 2023

3

Min Read

[NCLT] Amounts Payable under Successful Resolution Plan Do Not Constitute Financial Debt

NCLT rules that plan payments are not 'financial debt' under IBC s.7.

Cover image for the article: IBBI issues the Insolvency Professionals Panel Guidelines, 2023

21 Dec 2023

3

Min Read

IBBI Issues the Insolvency Professionals Panel Guidelines, 2023

Introduction In a proactive move to enhance the efficiency of insolvency resolution and liquidation proceedings, the Insolvency and...

Cover image for the article: The Tribunal Upholds the Validity of Investigations Under S. 213 of the Companies Act, 2013 During CIRP and Liquidation Proceedings

21 Dec 2023

3

Min Read

The Tribunal Upholds the Validity of Investigations under S. 213 of the Companies Act, 2013 During CIRP and Liquidation Proceedings

NCLT directs probe into Vikram Structures for illegal sales exceeding 243,037 sq. ft., misappropriating Rs. 136.5 crores.

Cover image for the article: Karnataka High Court Quashes CoC Resolutions Over Procedural Irregularities

30 Nov 2023

3

Min Read

Karnataka High Court Quashes CoC Resolutions over Procedural Irregularities

Karnataka HC enforces fairness in insolvency, invalidating a CoC decision due to notice flaws

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court Upholds Constitutional Validity of Ss. 95 to 100 of the IBC Provisions Relating to Personal Guarantors

23 Nov 2023

4

Min Read

Supreme Court Upholds Constitutional Validity of Ss. 95 to 100 of the IBC Provisions Relating to Personal Guarantors

Landmark SC ruling affirms key IBC sections, ensuring fair insolvency processes for personal guarantors.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court’s Landmark Decision: Equal Treatment to Government’s Secured Claims in IBC Cases

05 Nov 2023

3

Min Read

Supreme Court’s Landmark Decision: Equal Treatment to Government’s Secured Claims in IBC Cases

Introduction Recently in the case of Sanjay Kumar Agarwal v. State Tax Officer & Anr. , the Supreme Court of India ( ‘SC’ ) dismissed a batch of review petitions filed against the case of Rainbow Papers Limited

Cover image for the article: [SC] Property not exempt under SARFAESI Act if merely shown as agricultural land in revenue records

20 Jan 2023

4

Min Read

[SC] Property Not Exempt under SARFAESI Act if Merely Shown as Agricultural Land in Revenue Records

The Supreme Court has recently held in K Sreedhar v Raus Construction Pvt Ltd 2023 SCC OnLine SC 13 that merely because certain...

Cover image for the article: MCA proposes key changes to IBC, seeks public comments

19 Jan 2023

4

Min Read

MCA Proposes Key Changes to IBC, Seeks Public Comments

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) has, vide its notice dated 18th January 2023, proposed key amendments to the Insolvency and...