Cover image for the article: ITAT: Royalty Payments In Consonance with RBI Guidelines Exempt from TP Adjustments

08 Jun 2024

ITAT: Royalty Payments in Consonance with RBI Guidelines Exempt from TP Adjustments

3

Min Read

Cover image for the article: ITAT: Royalty Payments In Consonance with RBI Guidelines Exempt from TP Adjustments

08 Jun 2024

ITAT: Royalty Payments in Consonance with RBI Guidelines Exempt from TP Adjustments

3

Min Read

Cover image for the article: ITAT: Royalty Payments In Consonance with RBI Guidelines Exempt from TP Adjustments

08 Jun 2024

ITAT: Royalty Payments in Consonance with RBI Guidelines Exempt from TP Adjustments

3

Min Read

Introduction

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Ahmedabad (‘ITAT’), while dismissing the revenue’s appeal in the case of Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax v. Invida India (P) Ltd.[^i] held that Invida India (‘Assessee’) had rightly determined the arm’s length price (‘ALP’) for payment of royalty using the external comparable uncontrolled price (‘CUP’) method. This determination was made in accordance with the Reserve Bank of India (‘RBI’) guidelines, with the Assessee having fulfilled all the necessary criteria and documentation requirements for applying the aforementioned method.

Brief Facts

  • The Assessee was engaged in the business of trading pharmaceutical products on a wholesale basis with respect to phone products. The Assessee had entered into a 5-year ‘Brand Licencing Agreement’ (‘Licence Agreement’) with its Singapore-based associate enterprise (‘AE’). The Licence Agreement granted the Assessee the marketing, manufacturing and distribution rights for two products, against which the Assessee was liable to pay royalty @5% of their net sales.

  • The Assessee determined the ALP for the aforementioned international transaction by applying the external CUP method. However, pursuant to the notices issued under ss. 143(2) and 142(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (‘IT Act’), the Assessing officer (‘AO’), dissatisfied by the ALP determined by the Assessee, held the same to be incorrect and erroneous, and accordingly made transfer pricing (‘TP’) adjustments. The AO disputed that in addition to the royalty payments of the Assesses, its payment for management fees and IT allocation costs were not made at an ALP.

  • The Assessee filed an appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals) [‘CIT(A)’], whereby the rate of 5% of net sales for royalty determination was allowed, and all additions made by the AO were deleted. Aggrieved by the order passed by the CIT(A), the revenue approached the ITAT.

Held

  • The ITAT, while upholding the order passed by the CIT(A), observed that the payment of royalty was made keeping in mind the rate at which royalty payment is allowed by the Indian regulatory authorities, i.e., the RBI. The Assessee had furnished all relevant documents and duly fulfilled the criteria envisaged under r. 10D of the IT Rules, 1962.

  • It was held that the use of the CUP method was most suited for calculating ALP in the present case, and considering that the AO had failed to establish the reason why the CUP method was not applicable in the Assessee’s case, the contention of the revenue was not justified. The ITAT noted that the Assessee had provided sufficient evidence to support its allocation of costs and to demonstrate that the markup of 15% was reasonable.

Our Analysis

In the aforementioned case, the order passed by the ITAT reaffirms the importance of meticulous compliance in matters concerning TP regulations, which can often help businesses uphold bases during tax scrutiny. Further, the ruling also establishes a higher burden of responsibility on the AO while conducting TP assessments. Instances where the AO fails to conclusively establish his case before the appellate authorities invariably result in the deletion of unsubstantiated adjustments. Additionally, this decision highlights the significance of proper documentation and benchmarking in TP cases and its importance in substantiating arm’s length transactions.

End Note

[^i]: (2024) 163 taxmann.com 510 (Ahmedabad)

Authored by Anshi Bhatia at Metalegal Advocates. The views expressed are personal and do not constitute legal opinion.

Portrait of Anshi Bhatia
Portrait of Anshi Bhatia

AUTHORED BY

Principal Associate

Principal Associate

Principal Associate

More Insights

Cover image for the article: A Game of Treasure Hunt: Service of GST Notices and Orders under S. 169 of the CGST Act and the Emerging Split Among High Courts

25 Aug 2026

12

Min Read

A Game of Treasure Hunt: Service of GST Notices and Orders under S. 169 of the CGST Act and the Emerging Split among High Courts

Luxmi Traders addresses a fundamental question in GST adjudication: can a notice or order be treated as duly served merely because it is uploaded on the Common Portal? The Punjab and Haryana High Court held that portal-only service, absent the requisite statutory and notified basis, cannot by itself defeat a taxpayer’s remedies. With Madras and Allahabad adopting different approaches and Delhi subsequently applying Luxmi Traders, the issue reflects a significant divergence in judicial approach awaiting authoritative resolution.

Cover image for the article: Faceless Reassessment after S. 147A: What the Supreme Court Did – and Did Not – Decide

10 Jul 2026

7

Min Read

Faceless Reassessment after S. 147A: What the Supreme Court Did – and Did Not – Decide

The Supreme Court's decision in Tej Pratap Singh does not settle the JAO–FAO controversy. Following Parliament's retrospective insertion of s. 147A, it remands the issue to the High Courts for fresh consideration. Faceless reassessment was never merely about moving tax files from paper to portal; it fundamentally changed the statutory authority responsible for communicating with the taxpayer, examining the record, drafting the order and completing the assessment. The real question now is how far a retrospective legislative clarification can go.

Article cover for Mandatory Pre-Deposit for Appeals in Indirect Tax Laws: A Barrier to Justice?

23 Apr 2026

18

Min Read

Mandatory Pre-Deposit for Appeals in Indirect Tax Laws: A Barrier to Justice?

Mandatory pre-deposit has become a defining feature of indirect tax litigation, balancing revenue protection with access to appellate remedies. While the shift to a fixed statutory framework has improved procedural efficiency, it also raises concerns regarding financial barriers and effective access to justice. This insight examines the legal evolution, judicial interpretation, and practical implications of the regime.

Cover image for the article: Beyond Procedural Lapse: Delhi High Court Rules GST Proceedings Against Non-Existent Entity Void ab initio

13 Jun 2025

4

Min Read

Beyond Procedural Lapse: Delhi High Court Rules GST Proceedings against Non-Existent Entity Void Ab Initio

The Delhi High Court in HCL Infosystems Ltd. v. Commissioner of State Tax reaffirmed that GST proceedings against a company dissolved due to amalgamation are void ab initio. The Court held that such actions are not curable under section 160 of the CGST Act, nor authorised by section 87. This judgment aligns with the Supreme Court’s ruling in Maruti Suzuki, reinforcing the principle that legal proceedings cannot be pursued against non-existent entities.

Cover image for the article: [Patna HC] Appellate Authorities Under GST Must Decide Appeals on Merits, Not Technicalities

03 Jun 2025

4

Min Read

[Patna HC] Appellate Authorities under GST Must Decide Appeals on Merits, Not Technicalities

In M/s Silverline v. State of Bihar, the Patna High Court held that GST appellate authorities must adjudicate appeals on their merits, even in cases of procedural lapses or absence of supporting documents. The Court ruled that dismissal for non-prosecution without a merit-based inquiry violates statutory duty under s. 107 of the Bihar GST Act reinforces the importance of reasoned, fair, and substantive appellate decisions.

Cover image for the article: Bombay High Court Upholds Commercial Expediency for Deductions & Sets Boundaries on AO Jurisdiction under Section 115J of the Income-tax Act

22 May 2025

5

Min Read

Bombay High Court Upholds Commercial Expediency for Deductions & Sets Boundaries on AO Jurisdiction under Section 115J of the Income-Tax Act

The Bombay High Court, in a decisive ruling, upheld the allowability of business expenditure incurred by Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. in supporting its distressed subsidiary. The Court reaffirmed that commercial expediency justifies such deductions under Sections 28 and 37 of the Income-tax Act, 1961. It also clarified that the Assessing Officer has limited jurisdiction under Section 115J, reinforcing the sanctity of audited financials prepared under the Companies Act.

Cover image for the article: Provisional Attachment Under GST: Bombay High Court Sets Aside Provisional Attachment of Bank Account for Procedural Lapses

22 May 2025

4

Min Read

Provisional Attachment under GST: Bombay High Court Sets Aside Provisional Attachment of Bank Account for Procedural Lapses

In a significant ruling, the Bombay High Court quashed the provisional attachment of a bank account under the MGST Act, citing procedural lapses and absence of a reasoned order. The Court reiterated that such coercive powers must be exercised judiciously, based on tangible material, and not on presumptions. This decision reinforces judicial scrutiny of arbitrary use of powers under Section 83 of the GST regime.

Cover image for the article: Reasonable Cause Trumps Rigidity: Chhattisgarh High Court Holds Section 273B Overrides Mechanical Levy of Penalty Under Section 271E of the Income-tax Act

11 May 2025

5

Min Read

Reasonable Cause Trumps Rigidity: Chhattisgarh High Court Holds Section 273B Overrides Mechanical Levy of Penalty under Section 271E of the Income-Tax Act

Does every procedural lapse under the Income-tax Act deserve a penalty? Not quite. In a notable judgment, the Chhattisgarh High Court held that Section 273B offers a crucial safeguard—reasonable cause can shield genuine transactions from automatic penalty under Section 271E. The Court set aside a penalty where the cash repayment of a loan was made under the financier’s insistence, affirming that law must balance compliance with fairness.

Cover image for the article: ITAT: Section 56(2)(vii)(b) Not Retrospectively Applicable to Property Purchased Under Pre-Amendment Agreement

28 Apr 2025

5

Min Read

ITAT: Section 56(2)(vii)(b) Not Retrospectively Applicable to Property Purchased under Pre-Amendment Agreement

The ITAT Nagpur Bench has held that Section 56(2)(vii)(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 cannot be retrospectively applied to property transactions based on agreements executed prior to its commencement. In allowing the assessee’s appeal, the Tribunal reaffirmed that taxing provisions must apply prospectively unless explicitly stated otherwise, protecting pre-amendment transactions from adverse retrospective tax consequences.

Cover image for the article: [ITAT] No DTAA Relief Where POEM Lies Outside Both Contracting States

17 Apr 2025

5

Min Read

[ITAT] No DTAA Relief Where POEM Lies Outside Both Contracting States

The Mumbai ITAT ruled that Bay Lines (Mauritius) was not entitled to treaty relief under the India–Mauritius DTAA as its place of effective management (POEM) was in the UAE. The Tribunal also held that its Indian agent did not constitute a dependent PE. This dual ruling clarifies the evidentiary threshold for POEM and reaffirms the independent agent exception under international tax law.

Cover image for the article: ITAT: Payments by Deloitte India for Internal Brand, Communication, and Tech Services Not Royalty under Article 13 of the India–UK DTAA

13 Apr 2025

5

Min Read

ITAT: Payments by Deloitte India for Internal Brand, Communication, and Tech Services Not Royalty under Article 13 of the India–UK DTAA

The ITAT Mumbai held that payments made by Deloitte India to a UK-based affiliate for internal branding, technology, and communication services do not qualify as "royalty" under Article 13 of the India–UK DTAA. As there was no transfer of intellectual property, copyright, or commercial exploitation, the tribunal ruled that no TDS obligation arose. This reinforces jurisprudence around intra-network service arrangements and cost-sharing.

Cover image for the article: CBDT Notifies ITR-B for Search-Related Income Tax Returns: A Step Toward Streamlined Block Assessments

13 Apr 2025

4

Min Read

CBDT Notifies ITR-B for Search-Related Income Tax Returns: A Step Toward Streamlined Block Assessments

The CBDT has notified Form ITR-B as a new income tax return form specifically for block assessments arising from search and seizure actions. Effective retrospectively from 01.09.2024, the new r. 12AE introduces procedural clarity, a digital filing framework, and enables stricter scrutiny of undisclosed income and tax credit claims. This marks a key shift toward structured compliance in high-stakes search proceedings under ch. XIV-B.

Cover image for the article: Tribunal Affirms Tax Exemption for FPIs on Rights Entitlements under the India-Ireland DTAA

10 Apr 2025

4

Min Read

Tribunal Affirms Tax Exemption for FPIs on Rights Entitlements under the India-Ireland DTAA

The ITAT Mumbai ruled in favour of Vanguard, holding that gains from sale of rights entitlements by FPIs are not taxable in India under Article 13(6) of the India-Ireland DTAA. The Tribunal distinguished REs from shares and disallowed the Revenue’s attempt to offset exempt gains against Indian capital losses. This judgment reinforces treaty-based protections and clarity on the treatment of financial instruments distinct from equity.

Cover image for the article: Tribunal: Capital Gains Not Applicable on Family Settlements under Section 47(iii)

09 Apr 2025

4

Min Read

Tribunal: Capital Gains Not Applicable on Family Settlements under Section 47(iii)

The ITAT clarified that mutual settlement deeds between brothers, executed to preserve family harmony, are not ‘transfers’ under Section 2(47) and thus fall within the exemption provided under Section 47(iii) of the Income-tax Act. The decision reiterates that genuine family arrangements, executed without monetary consideration, cannot be subjected to capital gains tax. This sets a precedent on interpreting intra-family property settlements.

Cover image for the article: CBDT Issues Clarificatory FAQs for the 2024 Guidelines on Compounding of Offences Under the Income-tax Act, 1961

01 Apr 2025

7

Min Read

CBDT Issues Clarificatory FAQs for the 2024 Guidelines on Compounding of Offences under the Income-Tax Act, 1961

The CBDT has issued clarificatory FAQs to operationalise the 2024 Guidelines on compounding of offences under the Income-tax Act, 1961. This update explains the legal position on key procedural issues such as filing timelines, multi-jurisdictional applications, post-conviction compounding, and treatment of co-accused. The write-up unpacks the framework and highlights areas where discretion remains with the tax authorities.

Cover image for the article: Gauhati High Court Holds Excise Duty Exemption as Capital Receipt, Excludable From MAT Computation Under Section 115JB

30 Mar 2025

5

Min Read

Gauhati High Court Holds Excise Duty Exemption as Capital Receipt, Excludable from MAT Computation under Section 115JB

The Gauhati High Court, in Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Greenply Industries Ltd., held that excise duty exemptions granted under a notified industrial policy constitute capital receipts. Consequently, such receipts are neither taxable under regular provisions of the Income-tax Act, 1961 nor includible in book profits for MAT purposes under section 115JB.

Cover image for the article: ITAT Chennai Clarifies Non-Taxability of Accrued Interest on NPA for Co-operative Banks

27 Mar 2025

4

Min Read

ITAT Chennai Clarifies Non-Taxability of Accrued Interest on NPA for Co-Operative Banks

In a pivotal decision, the ITAT Chennai held that accrued interest on non-performing assets (NPAs) is not taxable for co-operative banks if not credited to the profit and loss account, in compliance with RBI guidelines. This ruling reinforces the legal principle that RBI norms on income recognition, under Section 45Q of the RBI Act, override the provisions of the Income-tax Act, even prior to the 2018 amendment to Section 43D.

Cover image for the article: Section 54 v. Section 54F: Tribunal Clarifies Capital Gains Exemption on Sale of Residential Property and Upholds Alternative Relief

27 Mar 2025

3

Min Read

Section 54 v. Section 54F: Tribunal Clarifies Capital Gains Exemption on Sale of Residential Property and Upholds Alternative Relief

The Jaipur ITAT’s ruling in Jai Singh Sethia v. DCIT/ACIT clarifies the distinction between Sections 54 and 54F under the Income-tax Act, 1961. The Tribunal denied exemption under Section 54F due to the property’s residential classification but granted relief under Section 54, reaffirming that procedural lapses should not defeat substantive tax relief when eligibility conditions are otherwise satisfied.

Cover image for the article: Bombay High Court Reaffirms: CBDT Guidelines Cannot Override Statutory Powers in Tax Compounding Cases

19 Mar 2025

2

Min Read

Bombay High Court Reaffirms: CBDT Guidelines Cannot Override Statutory Powers in Tax Compounding Cases

Bombay High Court reaffirms that statutory law prevails over CBDT guidelines in compounding offences under income tax legislation.

Cover image for the article: Appellate Tribunal on Section 269SS: No Penalty for Bank-Transferred Loans Recorded via Journal Entry

19 Mar 2025

5

Min Read

Appellate Tribunal on Section 269SS: No Penalty for Bank-Transferred Loans Recorded via Journal Entry

The ITAT Mumbai held that recording a bank-transferred loan via a journal entry does not violate s. 269SS of the Income-tax Act. The decision reinforces that substance prevails over form in genuine business transactions, especially where funds are routed through banking channels and properly documented.

Cover image for the article: Section 153C Validly Invoked on Basis of WhatsApp Chats Corroborated by Evidence: Rajasthan High Court

19 Mar 2025

4

Min Read

Section 153C Validly Invoked on Basis of WhatsApp Chats Corroborated by Evidence: Rajasthan High Court

Rajasthan High Court upholds Section 153C action based on WhatsApp chats corroborated by digital records and cash book evidence.

Cover image for the article: ITAT: Corporate Restructuring Must Meet All Conditions of Section 2(19AA) to Avoid Capital Gains Tax on Demerger

16 Mar 2025

4

Min Read

ITAT: Corporate Restructuring Must Meet All Conditions of Section 2(19AA) to Avoid Capital Gains Tax on Demerger

ITAT rules that failure to transfer liabilities with assets disqualifies a demerger from tax exemption under Section 2(19AA) of the IT Act.

Cover image for the article: Delhi HC Interprets Section 153C: Incriminating Material Alone Sufficient to Assess Non-Searched Persons

13 Mar 2025

5

Min Read

Delhi HC Interprets Section 153C: Incriminating Material Alone Sufficient to Assess Non-Searched Persons

The Delhi High Court, in Shiv Prakash Bansal v. DCIT, reaffirmed that proceedings under Section 153C of the Income-tax Act can be initiated solely on incriminating material found during a search, without requiring any nexus between the searched and non-searched persons. This judgment strengthens the Department’s power to act on discovered evidence, even against third parties not named in the search warrant.

Cover image for the article: Karnataka High Court Upholds DCF Method: Clarifies Degree of Satisfaction Required for AO to Reject Assessee’s Valuation Method

04 Mar 2025

5

Min Read

Karnataka High Court Upholds DCF Method: Clarifies Degree of Satisfaction Required for AO to Reject Assessee’s Valuation Method

In a notable decision, the Karnataka High Court affirmed that the DCF method, when used in compliance with Rule 11UA(2), cannot be disregarded without a reasoned and case-specific analysis. The ruling reinforces that Revenue authorities must exercise subjective satisfaction, backed by substantive evidence, before invoking Section 56(2)(viib) to tax share premiums.

Cover image for the article: No Assessment Without Proper Notice: ITAT Clarifies the Procedural Backbone of Assessments under the Black Money Act

02 Mar 2025

7

Min Read

No Assessment without Proper Notice: ITAT Clarifies the Procedural Backbone of Assessments under the Black Money Act

In a decisive ruling, the ITAT Mumbai held that a BMA assessment cannot be sustained without a valid notice under section 10(1), reinforcing that procedural compliance is not a mere formality but a jurisdictional precondition. The case underscores the interplay between notice issuance, deemed acquisition under section 72(c), and the consequences of retrospective taxation under the Black Money regime.

Cover image for the article: Delhi High Court: Violation of Section 269ST of the Income-tax Act Does Not Render Contract Void or Bar Recovery Claims

28 Feb 2025

4

Min Read

Delhi High Court: Violation of Section 269ST of the Income-Tax Act Does Not Render Contract Void or Bar Recovery Claims

Delhi HC clarifies that cash violations under Section 269ST don't void contracts; unjust enrichment cannot override contractual claims.

Cover image for the article: Whether Royalty is a Tax or a Fee for Service? A 9-Judge Constitution Bench Answers this Question in a Landmark Ruling, Applicable Retrospectively

28 Feb 2025

5

Min Read

Whether Royalty Is a Tax or a Fee for Service? A 9-Judge Constitution Bench Answers This Question in a Landmark Ruling, Applicable Retrospectively

SC clarifies whether royalty on minerals is a tax or a fee, reaffirming state powers in a landmark ruling with retrospective effect.

Cover image for the article: ITAT Resolves Conflicting Views and Allows Full Deduction of PE Expenses under the Pre-Amended Article 7(3) of the India-UAE DTAA

27 Feb 2025

6

Min Read

ITAT Resolves Conflicting Views and Allows Full Deduction of PE Expenses under the Pre-Amended Article 7(3) of the India-UAE DTAA

Special Bench of ITAT rules in favour of Mashreq Bank, allowing full PE expense deductions under pre-2008 India–UAE tax treaty.

Cover image for the article: From the Finance Act, 2021 to the Decisions in Ashish Agarwal & Rajeev Bansal: Delhi HC Clarifies Key Aspects of Reassessment under the Income-tax Act

26 Feb 2025

6

Min Read

From the Finance Act, 2021 to the Decisions in Ashish Agarwal & Rajeev Bansal: Delhi HC Clarifies Key Aspects of Reassessment under the Income-Tax Act

The Delhi High Court clarifies reassessment timelines, approvals, and JAO powers under the faceless regime post Finance Act, 2021.

Cover image for the article: Supreme Court: Statutory Amendments Cannot Retrospectively Extinguish Vested Tax Exemptions

26 Feb 2025

4

Min Read

Supreme Court: Statutory Amendments Cannot Retrospectively Extinguish Vested Tax Exemptions

SC rules that statutory amendments apply prospectively and cannot extinguish vested tax exemptions granted under unamended law.